New editions of the State Legislative Tracker and The Policy Tracker available now!

Supreme Court of North Carolina

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Supreme Court of North Carolina
200pxSSCBadgeforVNT.png
Court information
Justices:   7
Founded:   1799
Location:   Raleigh, North Carolina
Salary
Chief:  $144,049
Associates:  $140,285
Judicial selection
Method:   Nonpartisan election of judges
Term:   8 years
Active justices

North Carolina  •  Beverly Perdue  •  Elaine Marshall  •  Roy Cooper  •  History of Initiative & Referendum in North Carolina  •  North Carolina General Assembly  •  North Carolina media  •  Recount laws in North Carolina  •  WikiProject North Carolina  •  John M. Blust  •  William A. Current, Sr.  •  Timothy K. Moore  •  Edgar V. Starnes  •  Austin M. Allran  •  Tom Apodaca  •  Bob Atwater  •  Marc Basnight  •  Doug Berger  •  Phil Berger  •  Stan Bingham  •  Harris Blake  •  Andrew C. Brock  •  Harry Brown  •  Peter S. Brunstetter  •  Dan Clodfelter  •  Janet Cowell  •  Walter H. Dalton  •  Charlie Smith Dannelly  •  Don East  •  Tony Foriest  •  James Forrester  •  Linda Garrou  •  Steve Goss  •  Malcolm Graham (North Carolina)  •  Fletcher L. Hartsell, Jr.  •  Neal Hunt  •  Clark Jenkins  •  Eleanor Kinnaird  •  Vernon Malone  •  Martin L. Nesbitt, Jr.  •  Jean Preston  •  William R. Purcell  •  Joe Sam Queen  •  John Snow  •  Richard Stevens  •  A. B. Swindell  •  Jerry W. Tillman  •  Efton Sager  •  Patricia McElraft  •  George Cleveland  •  Carolyn Justice  •  Daniel McComas  •  N. Leo Daughtry  •  James Langdon, Jr.  •  Nelson Dollar  •  Paul Stam  •  Marilyn Avila  •  Jamie Boles  •  David Lewis, Sr.  •  Justin Burr  •  Patricia Hurley  •  Dale Folwell  •  Fred Steen, II  •  Harold Brubaker  •  Julia Howard  •  Jerry Dockham  •  Jeffrey Barnhart  •  Linda Johnson  •  Phillip Frye  •  Mitch Gillespie  •  Mitchell Setzer  •  Hugh Blackwell  •  Sarah Stevens  •  Bryan Holloway  •  Darrell McCormick  •  Shirley Randleman  •  Grey Mills, Jr.  •  Mark Hilton  •  Johnathan Rhyne  •  Thom Tillis  •  Ruth Samuelson  •  Ric Killian  •  Wil Neumann  •  W. David Guice  •  Roger West (North Carolina)  •  William Owens, Jr.  •  Timothy Spear  •  Alice Underhill  •  Annie Mobley  •  Arthur Williams (North Carolina legislator)  •  Angela Bryant  •  Edith Warren  •  Marian McLawhorn  •  Van Braxton  •  William Wainwright  •  Dewey Hill  •  Larry Bell  •  William Brisson  •  Joe Tolson  •  Jean Farmer-Butterfield  •  Michael Wray  •  Larry Hall  •  Paul Luebke  •  Henry Michaux, Jr.  •  Dan Blue  •  Grier Martin  •  Jennifer Weiss  •  Deborah Ross  •  Darren Jackson  •  Ty Harrell  •  Marvin Lucas, Jr.  •  Elmer Floyd  •  Margaret Dickson  •  Rick Glazier  •  Douglas Yongue  •  Garland Pierce  •  Lucy Allen  •  Bill Faison  •  Jimmy Love, Sr.  •  Joe Hackney  •  W.A. Wilkins  •  Verla Insko  •  Mary Harrison  •  Alma Adams  •  Margaret Jeffus  •  Earl Jones (North Carolina)  •  Alice Bordsen  •  Nelson Cole  •  Melanie Goodwin  •  Pryor Gibson  •  Larry Womble  •  Earline Parmon  •  Lorene Coates  •  Hugh Holliman  •  Cullie Tarleton  •  Tricia Cotham  •  Beverly Earle  •  Becky Carney  •  Martha Alexander  •  Kelly Alexander, Jr.  •  Susan Fisher  •  Jane Whilden  •  Ray Rapp  •  Robert Phillip Haire  •  Randy Stewart, North Carolina Representative  •  Larry Brown, North Carolina Representative  •  Bob Rucho  •  Ed Jones  •  Floyd McKissick  •  Donald Davis  •  David Rouzer  •  Josh Stein  •  Donald Vaughan  •  Debbie Clary  •  Governor of North Carolina  •  Lieutenant Governor of North Carolina  •  Attorney General of North Carolina  •  Dan Ingle  •  North Carolina Judicial Standards Commission  •  North Carolina stimulus allocations  •  North Carolina Open Government Coalition  •  John Locke Foundation  •  WRAL Public Records  •  North Carolina State Board of Elections  •  North Carolina Treasurer  •  North Carolina General Assembly Research Division  •  Frank Iler  •  Rosa Gill  •  Chris Heagarty  •  Diane Parfitt  •  North Carolina General Assembly Fiscal Research Division  •  Deliberative process exemption-North Carolina  •  Michael P. Walters  •  Private agency, public dollars-North Carolina  •  Hood Richardson  •  Barbara Garitty-Blake  •  C.B. Daughtridge  •  Richard Halbert  •  Louis Pate  •  Michael Schriver  •  Edward Redwine  •  William Rabon  •  James Leutze  •  Thom Goolsby  •  George "Dewey" Hudson  •  Brent Jackson  •  E.S. "Buck" Newton  •  Jody McCleod  •  Geoffrey Hurlburt  •  Marc Boudreau  •  Charles Malone (North Carolina)  •  John Beezley  •  Stephanie Watson  •  David Donovan  •  Roger Gerber  •  Wesley Meredith  •  Eric Mansfield  •  Ryan Hilliard  •  Wade Fowler  •  Rick Gunn  •  Jeffery Hyde  •  Patrick Phibbs  •  Barry Coe  •  Gladys Robinson  •  Trudy Wade  •  Richard Marshall  •  Nathan Jones  •  Edward McGuire (North Carolina)  •  Tommy Tucker  •  Colvin Edwards  •  John Aneralla  •  Cedric Scott  •  Annette Carter  •  Kathryn Harrington  •  Elizabeth Jones  •  Richard Evey  •  Warren Daniel  •  Ralph Hise  •  Daniel Soucek  •  Jon Dixon  •  R.L. Clark  •  Jim Davis  •  Mott Blair  •  Randy Hogsed  •  Dodie Allen  •  John Woodard  •  Samuel Edwards  •  Charles McGrady  •  Timothy Moffitt  •  Michael Cavallo  •  Kenneth Miller  •  Jacquelyn Smith  •  Edward Gambill  •  Mark Hollo  •  Mary Ostgaard  •  Cristina Vazquez  •  Lonnie Wilson  •  Kevin Furr  •  Theresa Yon  •  Ibrahim Oudeh  •  Glen Bradley  •  Charles Graham (North Carolina)  •  Norman Sanderson  •  William Cook (North Carolina)  •  Mark Griffin  •  Phillip Shepard  •  Susi Hamilton  •  DeAnn Poirier  •  Claiborne Holtzman  •  Paul Terrel  •  Robin Anderson  •  Duane Cutlip  •  Violet Rhineheart  •  Patricia Keever  •  John Carrol  •  Michael Hager  •  James Proctor (North Carolina)  •  Mary Accor  •  Kelly Hastings  •  John Eaker  •  John Torbett  •  Deborah Ware  •  Frank Deaton  •  William Brawley  •  Ann Newman  •  Rebecca Steen  •  Michael Wilson, North Carolina Politician  •  Rodney Moore  •  Gary Lafone  •  David Moulton  •  Jonathan Jordan  •  John Wolfe  •  David Munday  •  Walter Church  •  Rayne Brown  •  Harry Warren  •  John Magee  •  Johnie Barker  •  D. Craig Horn  •  James Parsons (North Carolina)  •  Roger Parker  •  Jeffery Simon  •  John Faircloth  •  Marcus Brandon  •  Darin Thomas  •  Cathy Wright  •  Richard Smith (North Carolina)  •  Michael Stone (North Carolina representative)  •  John Harry  •  Brawleigh Graham  •  Gaston Pridgen  •  Jacquelyn Warner  •  James Dixon (North Carolina)  •  Herbert Sobel  •  Matthew Peeler  •  Stanley Larson  •  Stephen LaRoque  •  Craig Hassler  •  Franklin Rivenbark  •  James Knox  •  Mary Dawson  •  Tristan Patterson  •  John Szoka  •  Garland Shepheard  •  Jeffrey Collins  •  Brian Allen  •  Patricia Ladd  •  Barbara Howe (North Carolina)  •  Steven Henion  •  Donald Frantz  •  Debera McHenry  •  Madison Shook  •  Johnny Dawkins  •  Thomas Murry  •  Jonathan Hardister  •  John May  •  Larry Kissell  •  Heath Shuler  •  Public Policy Polling  •  North Carolina transparency advocates  •  Neighbors Oversight for Open Government (www.nofog.info)  •  Bruce Davis  •  George Shaeffer  •  Jason Chambers  •  James Long (North Carolina)  •  Bert Jones  •  John Tarantino  •  Ken Goodman  •  North Carolina Secretary of State  •  North Carolina transparency grades  •  North Carolina State Auditor  •  North Carolina Superintendent of Public Instruction  •  North Carolina Commissioner of Insurance  •  Stan White  •  North Carolina Commissioner of Agriculture  •  North Carolina Secretary of Environment and Natural Resources  •  North Carolina Commissioner of Labor  •  North Carolina Utilities Commission  •  Steve Troxler  •  Cherie K. Berry  •  Wayne Goodwin  •  Archived North Carolina state budgets  •  Frank McGuirt  •  Beth Wood  •  Pat McCrory  •  Dee Freeman  •  June Atkinson  •  Edward Finley, Jr.  •  Department of Health, North Carolina  •  William Culpepper  •  Bryan Beatty  •  Susan Rabon  •  ToNola Brown-Bland  •  Employment Security Commission, North Carolina  •  Jason Saine  •  David W. Moore  •  Richard Burr  •  Kay Hagan  •  Tony Gurley  •  G.K. Butterfield  •  Renee Ellmers  •  Walter Jones  •  David Price  •  Virginia Foxx  •  Howard Coble  •  Mike McIntyre  •  Sue Wilkins Myrick  •  Patrick McHenry  •  Melvin Watt  •  Brad Miller  •  Treva Johnson  •  Ilario Pantano  •  Richard Hudson  •  Scott Keadle  •  Vernon Robinson  •  John Whitley  •  Fred Steen  •  Heath Wynn  •  Terry Bellamy  •  Timothy Murphy (North Carolina)  •  Cecil Bothwell  •  Dan Eichenbaum  •  Spence Campbell  •  Mark Meadows (North Carolina)  •  Vance Patterson  •  Paul Coble  •  Bill Randall  •  George Holding  •  Nathan Tabor  •  Ethan Wingfield  •  Richard Alexander  •  Ray Martin (North Carolina)  •  David Scholl  •  Chris Carney (North Carolina)  •  Wes Westmoreland  •  Frank Palombo  •  Michael Shaffer  •  Ken Fortenberry  •  Chris Petrella  •  John Tedesco  •  Mike Causey  •  Marlowe Foster  •  Antoinette Toni Morris  •  Jack Brosch  •  Lon Vernon Cecil  •  Robert Johnson (NC)  •  Dan Forest  •  Bob Etheridge  •  Doug Schell  •  Mike Beitler  •  AJ Daoud  •  Gary M. Dunn  •  Gardenia Henley  •  Jim Harney  •  George Hutchins  •  Richard Speer  •  Sonya Holmes  •  Clement Munno  •  Paul Wright  •  Charles Moss (North Carolina)  •  Kenn Gardner  •  Ed Goodwin  •  Doug Yopp  •  Elisabeth Motsinger  •  Steve Royal  •  Joseph Hank DeBragga  •  Greg Dority  •  Debra Goldman  •  Walter Smith  •  Scott Bryant  •  Tyrone Richardson  •  John C. Brooks (North Carolina)  •  Jim Allen (North Carolina)  •  Billy Yow  •  Jennifer Roberts  •  Dan Barry  •  Andy Dulin  •  Jim Pendergraph  •  Robert Pittenger  •  Jon Gauthier  •  Edwin Peacock  •  Hayden Rogers  •  Frank Roche  •  Ron Elmer  •  Fern Shubert  •  Rudy Wright  •  James McCall  •  Richard Morgan  •  Bill McManus  •  Tom Hill  •  Kenny West  •  Bernard A. Holliday  •  Bruce Blackmon  •  Scott Jones (North Carolina)  •  James Mahan (North Carolina)  •  Arthur Rich  •  Linda Coleman (North Carolina)  •  Mike Edwards (North Carolina)  •  Ken Leonczyk  •  Dan Whittacre  •  Pete DiLauro  •  Steve Wilkins  •  Darryl Holloman  •  Jim Bibbs  •  Brian Irving  •  Erik Anderson (North Carolina)  •  Tim D'Annunzio  •  Bruce G. Peller  •  Marcus W. Williams  •  Curtis Campbell  •  Don Peterson  •  Matt Newton  •  Jerry Evans  •  Greg Muse  •  Warren Scott Nail  •  Ken Jones  •  Randy Ramsey  •  Tony Moore (North Carolina)  •  Danny Hefner  •  Deb Butler  •  Clarence A. Bender  •  Brad Salmon  •  James Clark (North Carolina)  •  Sig Hutchinson  •  Erv Portman  •  George Tatum  •  Billy R. King  •  Eronomy Smith  •  Allen Thomas, Jr.  •  Curtis Worthy  •  Ben Clark  •  Kerry Sutton  •  Mike Woodard  •  Gene McLaurin  •  Daniel Wilson  •  Bobby R. Stanley  •  Mike Osborne  •  Dennis Nielsen  •  Donald S. Davis  •  Dan Miller  •  

Seal of North Carolina.png

The Supreme Court of North Carolina is the state's highest appellate court, and is located in Raleigh, North Carolina.

Justices

North Carolina Justice Building
The current justices of the court are:
JudgeTermSelected byParty
Chief Justice Mark Martin (North Carolina)1998-2022ElectionRepublican
Associate Justice Paul Martin Newby2004-2020ElectionRepublican
Associate Justice Robin Hudson2006-2022ElectionDemocratic
Associate Justice Robert H. Edmunds, Jr.2001-2016ElectionRepublican
Associate Justice Cheri Beasley2012-2022Gov. Bev PerdueDemocratic
Associate Justice Sam Ervin2015-2018ElectedDemocratic
Associate Justice Barbara Jackson2011-2018ElectionRepublican


Judicial selection

The court consists of six associate justices and one chief justice, although the number of justices has varied from time to time. Justices are chosen in nonpartisan elections to eight-year terms. If there is a vacancy in the court, a justice is chosen through the assisted appointment method of judicial selection. A justice who is appointed to a vacancy by the governor must run in an election that is at least 60 days after the vacancy occurred in order to serve a full term.[1]


In 1989, the Judicial Selection Study Commission released a report regarding judicial selection. The commission recommended that justices be appointed to a seat on the court. However, the idea did not gain enough support in the North Carolina House of Representatives to change the process.[2]

Qualifications

To serve on any court in North Carolina individuals must be:

  • attorneys
  • under the age of 72.[1][3]

Justices of the supreme court in North Carolina must retire before the last day of the month in which they turn 72.[4]

Chief justice

The chief justice of the North Carolina Supreme Court is elected by voters for eight-year terms.[1]

Jurisdiction

The primary function of the supreme court is to decide questions of law that have arisen in the lower courts and before state administrative agencies, including Court of Appeals cases that are reviewed upon petition.[5]

Caseloads

Fiscal Year Filings Dispositions
2014 730 704
2013 770 779
2012 744 688
2011 762 727
2010 769 753
2009 736 736
2008 773 794
2007 785 729

[6]

Elections

2014

For in-depth coverage of the state's high court races, see: North Carolina Supreme Court elections, 2014
Chief Justice
CandidateIncumbencyPrimary VoteElection Vote
MartinMark Martin (North Carolina)ApprovedAYes72.2%   ApprovedA
LewisOla M. Lewis No27.8%   DefeatedD
Hudson Seat
CandidateIncumbencyPrimary VoteElection Vote
DoranJeanette Kathleen Doran No20.9% 
HudsonRobin HudsonApprovedAYes42.5%ApprovedA52.5%   ApprovedA
LevinsonEric L. Levinson No36.6%ApprovedA47.5%   DefeatedD
Martin Seat
CandidateIncumbencyPrimary VoteElection Vote
HunterRobert N. Hunter, Jr. Yes47.4%   DefeatedD
ErvinSam ErvinApprovedANo52.6%   ApprovedA
Beasley Seat
CandidateIncumbencyPrimary VoteElection Vote
BeasleyCheri BeasleyApprovedAYes50.1%   ApprovedA
RobinsonMichael L. Robinson No49.9%   DefeatedD

Political outlook

See also: Political outlook of State Supreme Court Justices

In October 2012, political science professors Adam Bonica and Michael Woodruff of Stanford University attempted to determine the partisan outlook of state supreme court justices in their paper, State Supreme Court Ideology and 'New Style' Judicial Campaigns. A score above 0 indicated a more conservative leaning ideology while scores below 0 were more liberal. The state Supreme Court of North Carolina was given a campaign finance score (CFscore) which was calculated for judges in October 2012. At that time, North Carolina received a score of -0.01. Based on the justices selected, North Carolina was the 25th most liberal court. The study is based on data from campaign contributions by judges themselves, the partisan leaning of contributors to the judges or, in the absence of elections, the ideology of the appointing body (governor or legislature). This study is not a definitive label of a justice but rather, an academic gauge of various factors.[7]

Ethics

Judicial conduct

The North Carolina Code of Judicial Conduct consists of 7 canons:

  • A judge should uphold the integrity and independence of the judiciary.
  • A judge should avoid impropriety in all his activities.
  • A judge should perform the duties of his office impartially and diligently.
  • A judge may participate in cultural or historical activities or engage in activities concerning the legal, economic, educational, or governmental system, or the administration of justice.
  • A judge should regulate his extra-judicial activities to ensure that they do not prevent him from carrying out his judicial duties.
  • A judge should regularly file reports of compensation received for quasi-judicial and extra-judicial activities.
  • A judge may engage in political activity consistent with his status as a public official.[8][9]

The code can be read in full here.

Financial disclosure

See also: Center for Public Integrity Study on State Supreme Court Disclosure Requirements

In December 2013, the Center for Public Integrity released a study on disclosure requirements for state supreme court judges. Analysts from the Center reviewed the rules governing financial disclosure in each of the 50 states and the District of Columbia, as well as personal financial disclosures for the past three years. The study found that 42 states and Washington D.C. received failing grades. North Carolina earned a grade of F in the study. No state received a grade higher than "C". Furthermore, due in part to these lax disclosure standards, the study found 35 instances of questionable gifts, investments overlapping with caseloads and similar potential ethical quandaries. The study also noted 14 cases in which justices participated although they or their spouses held stock in the company involved in the litigation.[10]

History

Authority to create the body originated with the state's general assembly in the 1776 state constitution. The North Carolina State House served as the first home of the court. The state's highest court was officially named the "Supreme Court" and created in 1805, though at that time it was a group of four traveling superior court judges who reviewed the decisions made by the lower court. The modern supreme court was created in November 1818 and included a chief justice and associate judges. From 1818 until 1868, judges of the supreme court were elected by the general assembly.

  • 1799: In 1799, the first appellate true court, the "Court of Conference," was created in the state. The court sat en banc twice each year. In 1805, the court was renamed the "Supreme Court." In 1804, the court was ordered to write down their opinions and then read them out loud in court.[11]
  • 1818 to 1868: During this time, the justices on the court were selected by the General Assembly and served life terms. In the case of a vacancy, the governor appointed a replacement who would serve on the bench until the end of the next session of the General Assembly.[11]
  • 1868: The constitution of 1868 changed the judiciary in four primary ways:
  1. The court was created out of the constitution;
  2. The number of justices increased from three to five;
  3. Justice were elected by popular vote and served eight-year terms; and
  4. The "formerly separate law and equity jurisdictions of the Court into a single 'form of action for the enforcement or protection of private rights or the redress of private wrongs.'"[11]

Notable firsts

Susie Sharp was the first woman to serve as chief justice of the court. She began serving on the court in 1962 and held the position of chief justice between January 1975 and July 1979.[12]

Former justices

Courthouse

The supreme court is housed in the Law and Justice Building, located across from the North Carolina State Capitol in Raleigh, North Carolina. The building was designed by the architectural firm of Northrup & O'Brien and was completed in 1940.[14]

In the news

Governor Perdue appoints Timmons-Goodson's replacement (2012)

Cheri Beasley's appointment to the state's high court sparked some controversy, since the appointment was made by former Governor Bev Perdue without the advice of the North Carolina Judicial Nominating Commission.

When Patricia Timmons-Goodson announced her retirement, effective December 17, 2012, the commission told outgoing Governor Perdue that they would not be able to vet candidates for the vacancy before the end of her term. An executive order placed by Perdue in 2011 required her to choose court appointments from a list of candidates provided by the commission. However, she decided to bypass the commission and make the appointment herself before her time as governor ran out. She named Beasley to the high court on December 12, 2012.

Some decried Perdue's decision as a political move, since she was a Democrat and the newly-elected (at that time) Governor Pat McCrory was a Republican. Sen. Phil Berger, a Republican, stated, "It is increasingly clear that Gov. Perdue’s creation of the judicial screening commission was nothing short of a deceitful political charade."[15] Others defended Perdue's right to appoint justices to court vacancies, with or without the commission, as provided in Article IV, Section 19 of the state's constitution.[16]

See also

External links

References

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 American Judicature Society, "Methods of Judicial Selection: North Carolina," archived October 6, 2014
  2. North Carolina Legislature, "Report of the Judicial Selection Study Commission," February 15, 1989
  3. North Carolina Courts, "The North Carolina Judicial System," 2008
  4. North Carolina General Statutes, "General Statutes § 7A-4.20," accessed September 2, 2014
  5. The North Carolina Court System, "Supreme Court," accessed September 2, 2014
  6. The North Carolina Court System, "NC Judicial Branch Annual Reports"
  7. Stanford University, "State Supreme Court Ideology and 'New Style' Judicial Campaigns," October 31, 2012
  8. North Carolina Court System, "Code of Judicial Conduct," accessed October 8, 2014
  9. Note: This text is quoted verbatim from the original source. Any inconsistencies are attributed to the original source.
  10. Center for Public Integrity, "State supreme court judges reveal scant financial information," December 5, 2013
  11. 11.0 11.1 11.2 North Carolina Supreme Court Historical Society, "Battle Address," accessed February 3, 2014
  12. North Carolina Supreme Court Historical Society, "Justices of the Court," accessed February 3, 2014
  13. North Carolina Supreme Court Historical Society, "Justices of the NC Supreme Court," accessed October 16, 2014
  14. The North Carolina Court System, "A Brief History of the Justice Building," accessed September 2, 2014
  15. WRAL, "Perdue appoints Beasley to Supreme Court," December 12, 2012
  16. Associated Press via ABC Local, "Perdue to appoint state supreme court judge," November 29, 2012
North CarolinaSupreme Court of North CarolinaNorth Carolina Court of AppealsNorth Carolina Superior CourtsNorth Carolina District CourtsUnited States District Court for the Eastern District of North CarolinaUnited States District Court for the Middle District of North CarolinaUnited States District Court for the Western District of North CarolinaUnited States Court of Appeals for the Fourth CircuitNorth Carolina countiesNorth Carolina judicial newsNorth Carolina judicial electionsJudicial selection in North CarolinaNorthCarolinaTemplatewithoutBankruptcy.jpg