North Dakota Income Tax Cut, Measure 2 (2008)
|Measure 2 (2008)|
Election results via: The North Dakota Secretary of State.
The goal of the ballot initiative was to lower North Dakota's state corporate income tax rates by 15 percent and the adjusted state individual income tax rates by 50 percent for tax years beginning after December 31, 2008. The initiative would have amended sections 57-38-30 and 57-38-30.3 of the North Dakota Century Code.
- The North Dakota chapter of Americans for Prosperity sponsored the initiative. The chapter said that it wanted to make sure that "No taxpayer is left behind." AFP wanted the legislature to cut taxpayers a break given a possible surplus of over a billion dollars by 2009.
- The first signature on the initiative was that of former governor Ed Schafer, who endorsed the measure.
- The National Taxpayers Union supported Measure Two in the 2008 edition of its annual Ballot Guide, arguing that it could save North Dakota taxpayers $415 million annually.
- State Representative Blair Thoreson supported Measure Two.
Arguments made in support of the measure included:
- "The average family household earning $50,000 in taxable income would save around $500, that is real money to a lot of families. We should look at the surplus as an opportunity to increase the disposable income of the average family in North Dakota. We hear about North Dakota being a low wage state all the time, now is the time to declare that the state will be part of the solution to that problem, rather than adding to it."
- "Measure Two represents permanent and immediate tax relief for North Dakotans who have contributed to the vast state surplus everyone now agrees will exceed one-billion-dollars."
- "Last session, we spent 78 days debating how to provide tax relief to North Dakotans. However, the compromise we eventually approved expires soon. This measure will guarantee that taxpayers get long-term relief, not rebates based on what's might be agreed to each time the legislature meets."
- "Income tax revenues have nearly doubled in eight years, helping to produce the more than $1 billion in surplus in North Dakota. We can afford to give some of people’s money back to the working men and women of North Dakota–without hurting essential services and needs in the state."
- The Tax Foundation found in a recent study that North Dakota's economy is capable of handling the tax cuts, and that higher rates of economic growth will follow. Tax Counsel Joseph Henchman said, "If North Dakota moves in the direction of lowering tax burdens without undermining government services, there is a strong likelihood that better economic performance will follow," explaining that lower tax rates encourage innovation and investment.
A group called Partners to Protect North Dakota's Future opposed both the income tax measure and North Dakota Constitutional Measure 1 (2008).
Members of the coalition included:
- The North Dakota Education Association
- The North Dakota School Boards Association (NDSBA)
- American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME)
Other groups that opposed the measure were the North Dakota Farm Bureau, the North Dakota Rural Electric Cooperatives, and the North Dakota Board of Higher Education.
Arguments against Measure 2
Arguments in opposition to the measure included:
- It would hamper state and local governments’ and school boards’ ability to respond to emergencies or shifting priorities in the future.
- A cut might not be sustainable when the oil industry or economy takes a downturn.
Statutory Measure No. 2 would have lowered the state corporate income tax by 15 percent and cut the state personal income tax in half beginning in 2009. North Dakota was projected to have a $1.3 billion budget surplus, and this measure could have saved taxpayers over $415 million over two years.
Path to the ballot
On July 21st, 15,667 signatures were submitted for approval. On August 25, 2008, it was announced that the measure had qualified for the fall ballot. If the measure had passed, the changes to the tax code would have taken effect on January 1st, 2009.
- North Dakota attorney general says no taxpayer money for ballot measures
- North Dakota 2008 Initiatives
- Campaign finance requirements for North Dakota ballot measures
- North Dakota Initiative and Referendum Law
- North Dakota signature requirements
- Petition drive deadlines in 2008
- Income Tax Cut Ballot Language
- North Dakota chapter, Americans for Prosperity website. Initiative sponsors.
- National Taxpayers Union 2008 Ballot Guide
- Tax Foundation Fiscal Fact on Measure 2
- ND Measures 2008, initiative opponents
- Americans for Prosperity Announces Campaign to Bring Income Tax Measure Before Voters, Americans for Prosperity North Dakota Chapter
- ND Governor: Too early to talk about tax reform, NDPR radio, Dec. 3, 2007
- Former Governor Ed Schafer is First to Sign Petition for Initiated Measure to Cut Income Taxes, Americans for Prosperity, July 19, 2007
- List of groups in the Partners to Protect North Dakota's Future coalition
- AARP Of North Dakota Comes Out Against Tax Cut Initiated Measure, Say Anything Blog, Dec. 8, 2007
- North Dakota Farm Bureau Comes Out Against Tax Cuts, KX Blog, Nov. 21, 2007
- National Taxpayers Union
- Committee Submits Signatures for Initiated Income Tax Measure
- Group close to getting signatures for tax measure
- Bismarck Tribune, "N.D. tax measure approved for ballot despite possible fraud", August 26, 2008