Paul Brooks recall, Lumbee Tribe, North Carolina (2014)
An effort to recall Paul Brooks from his position as the Lumbee Tribe chairman in North Carolina was launched in January 2014. Brooks was accused of assaulting the former secretary of the Tribal Council while she was posting an explanation of the recall process of an elected official. He was charged with misdemeanor assault, though the charges were eventually dropped. Additionally, Brooks was found guilty in the Lumbee Supreme Court on six contempt of court charges. A recall campaign was led by a group calling itself the Lumbee Revolution. If Brooks had been recalled, it would have been the first instance of this in the Lumbee Tribe's history. However, the effort ultimately did not go to a vote.
On November 18, 2013, Louise Mitchell, then the secretary for the Lumbee Tribal Council, filed assault charges against Tribal Chairman Paul Brooks, claiming he "grabbed her arm and pushed her" during an altercation on November 13. Brooks admitted there had been an altercation but said no assault occurred. Robeson County District Attorney Johnson Britt reviewed the case and ultimately declined to press charges. Mitchell was upset with Johnson's decision, saying, "This is an injustice to me. I feel I was not treated fairly. I am highly disappointed in our judicial system in Robeson County. No one heard my story. I am a victim and the law is not working to protect me."
Regarding the allegations of assault, Brooks said, "I have maintained my innocence from the onset of this charge. It is unfortunate that this situation has taken up so much of the court’s time."
Path to the ballot
According to tribal rules, only registered, or "enrolled," tribal members who voted in the November 2012 Tribal Election - approximately 5,000 members - would have been able to participate in the recall campaign. Lumbee Law requires that, in order to recall Brooks, 20 percent of those who voted in November 2012 would have had to sign a recall petition requesting an election. Had enough signatures been collected and verified, then a recall election would have been held. If the majority of 30 percent of those who voted in the November 2012 election approved the recall, then Brooks would have been removed from office. Supporters of the recall were hoping for an April 2014 election.
- Fay Observer, "Members of the Lumbee Tribe seek to recall chairman," January 17, 2014
- Indianz.com, "Assault charge dropped against chairman of Lumbee Tribe," January 23, 2014
- Laurinburgexchange.com, "Tribal Council updated on recall push," January 17, 2014
- Robesonian.com, "Meeting on Tuesday to advance recall effort," February 7, 2014
- Robesonian.com, "Assault charge dropped against Brooks," January 22, 2014
- FayObserver.com, "Members of the Lumbee Tribe seek to recall chairman," January 17, 2014
State of North Carolina
|State executive officers||
Governor | Lieutenant Governor | Attorney General | Secretary of State | Treasurer | State Auditor | Superintendent of Public Instruction | Commissioner of Insurance | Commissioner of Agriculture | Secretary of Environment and Natural Resources | Commissioner of Labor | Chairman of Utilities |