Saginaw Public Schools recall, Michigan (2014)
An effort to recall three members of the Saginaw Board of Education in Michigan was initiated on February 14, 2014. Organizers filed petitions with the Saginaw County Clerk, but two attempts at recall language were deemed unclear by the county's election commission. The targeted members include Delena Spates-Allen, Alexis Thomas and Glenda Richardson-Vaughn.
As of August 15, 2014, no new recall petitions had been filed.
Recall supporter arguments
Recall organizer Margie Dallas sought to remove Spates-Allen, Thomas and Richardson-Vaughn due to concerns over long-term financial viability and the board's relationship with superintendent Carlton Jenkins. Dallas was worried that proposed school closures would lead to poor academic performance and overcrowding. The district also faced a $6.1 million deficit that must be resolved to avoid cancellation of state aid. Dallas also argued in her petition that the board is not following district policy by refusing to evaluate the superintendent. The board gave Jenkins an evaluation during a March 20 meeting and extended his contract through the 2016-2017 school year.
Delena Spates-Allen's response
Spates-Allen argued that the Board of Education could not evaluate the superintendent without an effective evaluation process. The board had not selected among three possible methods of evaluation as of January 2013. Spates-Allen noted that the board had until April to evaluate the superintendent.
Path to the ballot
- See also: Laws governing recall in Michigan
Recall organizers submitted recall petitions to the Saginaw County Clerk. The initial ballot language was rejected by a three-person election commission due to lack of clarity. Dallas submitted new ballot language, but the board rejected the revised petition as unclear during a March 31, 2014, meeting. As of August 15, 2014, no new recall petitions had been filed.
If petition language had been approved, organizers would have needed to collect signatures equaling 25 percent of all votes in the district during the previous gubernatorial election. The Saginaw City Clerk and the Saginaw County Clerk would have reviewed the signatures before approving a recall election.
- NBC25, "Recall petition filed against members of Saginaw Board of Education," February 14, 2014
- Lindsay Knake, MLive.com, "Second recall petition against three Saginaw school board members rejected," April 4, 2014
- Lindsay Knake, MLive.com, "Rejected: Recall petition for Saginaw school board members 'not clear enough'," March 3, 2014
- Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Susan Kaltenbach, Saginaw County Clerk," August 14, 2014
- Lindsay Knake, MLive.com, "Recall petition filed against 3 Saginaw School District board members," February 19, 2014
- Lindsay Knake, MLive.com, "Saginaw school board member: Recall me if I'm not doing a good job," February 23, 2014
- Michigan Secretary of State, "Election Official's Manual," January 2014
State of Michigan
|State executive officers||
Governor | Lieutenant Governor | Attorney General | Secretary of State | Treasurer | Auditor General | Superintendent of Public Instruction | Commissioner of Insurance | Director of Agriculture and Rural Development | Director of Natural Resources | Director of Labor and Economic Growth | Chairman of Public Service Commission |
Michigan Supreme Court | Supreme Court Elections | Court of Appeals | First Circuit Court of Appeals | Second Circuit Court of Appeals | Third Circuit Court of Appeals | Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals | List of Michigan Circuit Courts | Judicial Nominating Commission | Judicial news | Judicial activist organizations |