South Dakota Coffey Primary Election Law (1914)
The South Dakota Coffey Primary Election Law Initiative was on the November 3, 1914 ballot in South Dakota as an initiated state statute, where it was defeated. The measure would have largely repealed and replaced the Richard's Primary Law, which was an initiative approved by voters in 1912. That measure had revised the state's primary election system.
|South Dakota Coffey Primary Election Law Initiative (1914)|
Text of measure
|historical ballot measure article requires that the text of the measure be added to the page.|
Background & aftermath
This measure was a direct challenge to the 1912 Richards Law. The Richards Primary Law was named after its primary creator and sponsor, R. O. Richards of Huron, South Dakota. Richards was a candidate for United States Senate and served as the Republican state chairman. The work to replace the caucus system with a direct primary began strongly in 1903. In 1904, a petition to place the matter on the ballot as an initiated state statute was submitted with almost twice the number of required signatures, but was denied placement on the ballot by the legislature. Instead, the legislature passed the Honest Caucus Law, which retained the convention system with some new restrictions. This legislative move is credited as part of the reason for the election of Governor Coe Isaac Crawford (R) and a "progressive" legislature in 1906. This legislature passed a further revision of the convention system, which remained in place until 1912. In 1911, another initiated state statute was submitted on the same matter, and this time the legislature did not hinder its appearance on the ballot. That measure was approved by voters, but did not mark the end of the struggle for a direct primary in South Dakota.
The 1912 version of Richards Law created an extremely complex system for primary elections and was criticized for its expense and complications. Before the law even took effect, the legislature approved another initiated state statute for the 1914 ballot called the Coffey Law. It would have repealed the Richard's Law and replaced it with a more conventional primary system. This measure, however, was not approved by the voters. The 1912 law was allowed to go into effect.
While these two votes on the matter of direct primaries seemed to confirm the electorate's desire for direct primaries, the legislature enacted the Norbeck Law in 1915, which repealed the Richards law and substituted a more conventional primary system. The legislature enacted the measure with an emergency clause, making it impossible for a veto referendum to be called on the matter. The issue of legislative tampering by repealing initiated laws was challenged in the South Dakota Supreme Court, but the court upheld the constitutionality of such acts.
The legislative tampering led Richards to revise his law again. He secured its placement on the 1916 ballot, where it was narrowly defeated by 323 votes. However, Richards continued his attempts and secured the measure's placement on the 1918 ballot, where it was approved. This removed the Norbeck Law of 1915 and gave the state a direct primary system with strong public support.
- South Dakota 1914 ballot measures
- 1914 ballot measures
- List of South Dakota ballot measures
- History of Initiative & Referendum in South Dakota
- South Dakota Political Almanac, Table 7. Results of Elections Concerning State Constitutional Amendments and Initiated and Referred Laws, 1889-1968
- I&R Institute ballot measure database for South Dakota
- South Dakota Political Almanac, "Table 7. Results of Elections Concerning State Constitutional Amendments and Initiated and Referred Laws, 1889-1968," accessed May 22, 2014
- I&R Institute, "Ballot measure database for South Dakota," accessed June 30, 2014
- Berdahl, C. A. (1920) The Richards Primary. The American Political Science Review 14(1). 93-105.
State of South Dakota
|State executive officers||
Governor | Lieutenant Governor | Attorney General | Secretary of State | Treasurer | State Auditor | Secretary of Education | Director of Insurance | Secretary of Agriculture | Secretary of Environment and Natural Resources | Secretary of Labor | Chairman of Public Utilities |