A house divided over booze
July 29, 2011
Turzai has long been an advocate of the privatization of Pennsylvania's state-run liquor business. The commonwealth has had a monopoly on wholesale and retail liquor and wine sales since Prohibition ended in 1933. Turzai's bill moves to shut down Pennsylvania's 609 "state stores," as the commonwealth's liquor and wine stores have come to be known, and distribute 1,250 new retail licenses in a public auction. He estimates the sale would generate $1 billion to $2 billion in upfront revenue. Pennsylvania Treasurer Rob McCord estimates the auction would earn the commonwealth around $1.7 billion, while union leader Wendell Young, chairman of the United Food and Commercial Workers PA Wine and Spirit Council, puts the figure between $600 million and $700 million.
Faced with a deficit of nearly $4 billion, Pennsylvania could certainly use the cash, but even some Republicans are wary of Turzai's proposal. Representative Scott Petri expressed concern for the impact the law would have on existing restaurants and beer distributors, as well as the 5,000 Pennsylvanians who are currently employed by the Liquor Control Board. John Taylor, chairman of the House Liquor Control Committee, is careful to say he doesn't think the bill is a "slam-dunk," and expressed his interest in "taking a look at all the options." In the other chamber, Senate President Joe Scarnati believes the legislature should allow the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board to act more like a private business before selling the liquor system, suggesting the board should be permitted to set prices by region and experiment with market demands.
Turzai is confident in his bill, noting that government "is supposed to serve the people, not serve them alcohol." Governor Tom Corbett has expressed his support for the bill, and appears unperturbed by the failed efforts of his two most recent GOP predecessors who both tried (without success) to sell the state stores while they were in office. He has said he "looks forward to working with Representative Turzai and other members of the House and Senate to privatize the liquor system."
- DailyLocal.com, "Turzai unveils plan to privatize state liquor stores," July 14, 2011 (dead link)
- PittsburghLive.com, "Turzai liquor plan draws cheers, jeers," July 14, 2011
- TimesLeader.com, "Proposal to privatize state liquor stores detailed," July 13, 2011 (dead link)
- BusinessWeek.com, "House GOP leader outlines Pa. liquor store bill," July 13, 2011
- PittsburghLive.com, "House leader plans to take 'great care' with liquor bill," July 27, 2011
- The Morning Call, "Senate leader:No rush on taking booze biz private," July 21, 2011
- PittsburghLive.com, "State stores sale divides GOP," July 28, 2011