City of Ventura Sales Tax, Measure A (November 2009)
From Ballotpedia
A City of Ventura Sales Tax Increase, Measure A ballot proposition was on the November 3, 2009 ballot in Ventura County for voters in the City of Ventura, where it was defeated.[1]
- Yes: 8,709 (44.52%)
- No: 10,853 (55.48%)
The tax measure would have increased the city's sales tax by a half-cent, from 8.25% to 8.75%.[2]
It is estimated that if Measure A had passed, about $8-$10 million a year would have been raised for the City of Ventura in additional sales tax income.[3]
Supporters
Measure A supporters launched their "Yes on Measure A" campaign on September 26 with a rally in front of the H.P. Wright Library. With Ventura's troubled budget situation, The Wright Library might close. The Wright Library is one of three public libraries in Ventura.[4]
Supporters who spoke at the rally included Ventura Mayor Christy Weir and members of San Buenaventura Friends of the Library.
Weir spoke out in favor of Measure A since July to business and neighborhood groups such as the Rotary Club, a mobile home group, and the Midtown Ventura Community Council.[1]
Other supporters and the reasons they gave for supporting Measure A included:
- Brian Leshon of the Democratic Club of Ventura County, who said, "It’s a bitter pill, but we need to do it. … The state is stealing $4 million a year."[5]
- Jay Panzica, chief financial officer for Ventura, who said, "We’re operating at a lower level right now. The choice would be, ‘Do you like the level we’re at now, or do you want to pay more and get better service?’"[5]
- John Snowling, president of the Police Officers Association, who said the police department has been "...understaffed for a long time. A city our size should have at least 140 officers. All the violent crime we’ve had this year, it’s my opinion you can’t afford to lose any more."[5]
- The editorial board of the Ventura County Reporter. They wrote, "While we are cautious in endorsing this measure because of various questionable policies implemented by the council, such as the 911 fee, we believe that Ventura’s leaders will be accountable and will fund and put forth into action those things the community values so dearly."[6]
Opponents
- Don Facciano, President of the Ventura County Taxpayers Association, said that the Ventura City Council can't be trusted to spend money raised through Measure A the way it is currently saying it will spend it. He said, "This spending plan is a non-binding, advisory directive. They (City Council) say they know where they’re going to put it, but it doesn’t mean they can’t change it."[5]
- Bob McCord is a Ventura attorney who was one of four members of an ad-hoc Blue Ribbon Committee appointed by the city to research Measure A. He said, "The problem is if they spend it for the same reasons as over the past five years. What have you done historically to make me have confidence in you in the future?”[5]
- Bob Alviani was also on the ad-hoc Blue Ribbon Committee to study Measure A. He said, "There are people who will vote for this on the mere premise that it will help the Wright Library, but there’s no guarantee it will."[5]
- Clifton Tingstrom, a former mayor of Ventura, who said, "Our main complaint is, the council is not using their heads. You just can’t keep spending and figure when the economy is going down, you lay off the private sector. The ones who create a profit are from the private sector. It’s called capitalism."[5]
Other arguments made against Measure A include:
- Ventura has $172 million in combined investment and uncommitted reserves that it could use to fund emergencies during this time of economic decline.[5]
Ventura's budget
Ventura's general fund for fiscal year 2009-2010 is $85 million. $11 million has been cut and 42 employees have been laid off because of budget pressures due to the state-wide economic decline in California.[5]
See also
External links
- Ballot language, Measure A
- Full text of Measure A
- City attorney's impartial analysis of Measure A
- Arguments in favor of and against Measure A
- Rebuttals to arguments in favor of and against Measure A
- Measure A election results
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 Ventura County Star, "Ventura mayor rallies support for city sales-tax measure", July 30, 2009
- ↑ Ventura County Star, "Odds and ends from a blurry-eyed 'activist'", February 3, 2009
- ↑ Ventura County Star, "Campaign for half-cent sales tax increase begins", September 27, 2009
- ↑ Ventura County Star, "It's time to share the pain", January 31, 2009
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 Ventura County Reporter, "Ventura's sales tax measure leaves locals divided over city funding practices", October 15, 2009
- ↑ Ventura County Reporter, "Be responsible and vote this Election Day", November 22, 2009
| |||||
