Game not over: Opponents of Nevada sports arena file appeal with state high court
CARSON CITY, Nevada: As reported at the time in an earlier article, a ruling in favor of keeping the Nevada sports arena measure by a Nevada First Judicial District Court Judge could be appealed to the Nevada Supreme Court. That has now happened, as opponents of the measure, Taxpayers for the Protection of Nevada Jobs, is challenging the ruling of Judge Todd Russell that enough signatures were collected to place the initiative on the 2012 ballot.
The proposed initiative would allow a 20,000-seat sports arena on the Las Vegas Strip. Specifically it would impose a 0.9 cent sales tax in a taxing district near the proposed arena. The revenue would finance bonds to construct the sports venue.
According to Judge Russell, opponents who filed the lawsuit double counted invalid signatures. He also tossed the argument by the plaintiffs that the county clerks allegedly inflated signatures counts. According to reports, the plaintiffs, Taxpayers for the Protection of Nevada Jobs, can appeal to the Nevada Supreme Court, which the group is considering. No official word from the group has been made concerning this.
According to reports, the lawsuit argued that the petition circulation process was tainted by fraudulent behavior by engaging in the use of false advertisements. For example, the lawsuit points to the use of pervasive lies about the details of the initiative (including the location of the proposed arena) and false statements about who circulated the petitions and obtained the signatures.
More than 200,000 were filed with state officials on November 8, 2010. According to the Nevada Secretary of State's office, a total of 221,874 signatures were filed. The signatures were then returned to the state's counties for verification that 5 percent of the submitted signatures were registered voters.
In early December 2010 the Nevada Secretary of State verified that the measure had sufficient signatures to be referred to the legislature for consideration. The legislature had the option to act on the measure, such as implementing it without public vote, but did not. Since the lawmaking body declined to do so, the measure, currently, will appear on the 2012 ballot.
- Nevada Harrah's Sports Arena Initiative (2012)
- 2012 ballot measures
- Nevada 2012 ballot measures
- Laws governing the initiative process in Nevada
- List of Nevada ballot measures
- Las Vegas Sun, "Opponents of Las Vegas Strip arena proposal file appeal," May 17, 2011
- Las Vegas Sun, "Judge lets Harrah’s proceed with petition to build sports arena," September 21, 2010
- Las Vegas Sun, "Caesars Entertainment wins legal battle over proposed Strip arena," May 9, 2011
- Arena Digest, "Casinos file suit to block new Vegas arena," December 20, 2010