Maine Clearcutting Ban Versus Sustainable Forest Management Practices, Question 2 (1996)

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Voting on Forests and Parks
Forests and parks.jpg
Ballot Measures
By state
By year
Not on ballot
Maine
LawsHistory
List of measures

The Maine Clearcutting Ban Versus Sustainable Forest Management Practices Initiative, also known as Question 2, was on the November 5, 1996 ballot in Maine as an indirect initiated state statute, where the legislative competing measure, Option 2B was approved. The measure asked voters to choose between three options:[1][2][3]

  • Option 2A Citizen Initiative: Bans clearcutting and other new logging standards
  • Option 2B Competing Measure: Promotes sustainable forest management by making Compact for Maine's Forests law
  • Option 2C: Against options 2A and 2B

Because Option 2B did not receive more than half of the vote, it was resubmitted a single option to voters in 1997, where it was defeated.

See also: Competing initiatives in the laws governing the initiative process in Maine

Aftermath

See also: Maine Constitution, Article IV, Part Third, Section 18 & Maine Compact for Maine's Forest, Question 1 (1997)

In a three-way contest like this one, Maine's constitution requires that one of the options receive more than half of the votes to be approved and enacted. If no option succeeds in securing this, the measure receiving the majority is voted upon by itself at the next statewide election to be held no less than 60 days after the first vote. This was the case for Option 2B, as it only received 47.35 percent of the vote. It was placed on the November 4, 1997 ballot, where it was ultimately defeated.

Election results

Maine Question 2 (1996)
ResultVotesPercentage
Defeatedd Option 2A: Citizen Initiative 175,078 29.33%
Approveda Option 2B: Competing Measure 282,620 47.35%
Defeatedd Option 2C: Against A and B 139,176 23.32%

Election results via: Maine State Law and Legislative Reference Library, Votes on Initiated Bills 1980-

Text of measure

Maine 1996 sample ballot for statewide measures

The language appeared on the ballot as:[4]

QUESTION 2: (COMPLETE ONLY ONE ARROW)

2A: Citizen Initiative

Do you want Maine to ban clearcutting and set other new logging standards?

2B: Competing Measures

Do you want the Compact for Maine's Forests to become law to promote sustainable forest management practices throughout the State?

2C: Against A and B

Against both the Citizen Initiative and the Competing Measure.

[5]

Similar measures

See also

BP-Initials-UPDATED.png
Suggest a link

External links

References