Difference between revisions of "Laws governing the initiative process in Montana"

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
(External links)
(Legislative tampering)
Line 52: Line 52:
==Legislative tampering==
==Legislative tampering==
:: ''Main article: [[Legislative tampering]]''
:: ''Main article: [[Legislative tampering]]''
The legislature can both repeal and amend initiatives.
The [[Montana State Legislature]] can both repeal and amend {{issfull}}s (but not {{icafull}}s, except through the normal procedures for [[Amending state constitutions#Montana|amending the Montana Constitution]].)
==General comments==
==General comments==

Revision as of 19:11, 30 December 2009

Ballot law
BallotLaw final.png
State laws
Initiative law
Recall law
Statutory changes
Ballot Law Update
Current edition
Court cases
Lawsuit news
Ballot access rulings
Recent court cases
Petitioner access
Ballot title challenges
Superseding initiatives
Signature challenges
Local ballot measure laws
The first step in qualifying an initiative for the ballot in Montana is for its proponents to submit the full text of the initiative to the Montana Secretary of State for review. Within 14 days after receiving the measure, the Secretary of State's staff must make recommendations for changes in the text or, alternatively, provide a statement indicating that no changes are recommended. (See ballot title.) Proponents must consider the recommendations and respond in writing to the Secretary of State, either accepting, rejecting or modifying each recommended change.

A sample petition, including the complete text of the measure, must then be submitted to the Secretary of State’s office in the form in which it will be circulated. The ballot measure proponents must also submit a proposed impartial ballot statement to accompany the issue. The sample petition may not be submitted to the Secretary of State more than one year prior to the final date for filing the signed petition with the county election administrator. The Secretary of State refers a copy of the petition to the Montana Attorney General for approval. The Secretary of State and Attorney General must each review the petition for sufficiency as to form, approve or reject the form of the petition and state the reasons for rejection, if any.

The Attorney General must forward his or her comments to the Secretary of State within 21 days after receipt of the petition. The Secretary of State will send written notice of the initial approval or rejection of the form to the person who submitted the petition within 28 days after submission. If the petition form is approved, a printed sample copy of the petition to be circulated, containing the title and implication of the vote statements as prepared by the Attorney General, must be filed with the Secretary of State. The determination of legal sufficiency shall be forwarded to the Secretary of State within 30 days of the initial form approval. The Secretary of State will notify the sponsor of such a decision.

Fiscal statement

The Attorney General will also order a fiscal impact statement if the proposed ballot issue has an effect on the revenues, expenditures or the fiscal liability of the state. The budget director, in cooperation with the agency or agencies affected by the petition, is responsible for preparing the fiscal note. If a fiscal note is prepared for the proposed ballot issue, the Attorney General will prepare a fiscal statement that is to be used on the petition and ballot if the measure is placed on the ballot. The Attorney General also will write a statement, not to exceed 100 words, explaining the purpose of the measure, and statements, not to exceed 25 words each, explaining the implications for and against the measure. If one wishes to challenge an Attorney General's decision on whether or not a ballot is legally sufficient the case will go directly to the Montana Supreme Court.[1]

Number of signatures required

The number of signatures required to qualify a measure for the ballot is tied to how many votes were cast in the last gubernatorial election. To place a constitutional amendment on the ballot, proponents must collect 10% of votes cast for governor in the last gubernatorial general election. For the 2008 election cycle, that comes to 44,615 signatures. For a ballot measure to create a new state statute, 5% of votes cast for governor in the most recent gubernatorial election are required. For 2008, that comes to 22,308 signatures.

Distribution requirement

Montana has a distribution requirement. For ballot measures proposing amendments to the Montana Constitution, the requirement is that signatures equalling 10% of those who voted in the most recent gubernatorial election must be collected in each of at least 40 of the state's legislative districts. Ballot measures proposing changes to Montana's state statutes must collect signatures equalling 5% of those who voted in the most recent gubernatorial election in each of at least 35 legislative districts.

Circulation and submission deadline

The circulation period can be no more than one year. All signatures must be filed with the Secretary of State before 5 p.m. of the third Friday of the fourth month prior to the election at which they are to be voted upon by the people.[2] For 2010, that deadline will be June 18, 2010.

Method of signature verification

County officials check the names of all signers to verify they are registered voters. In addition, they randomly select signatures on each sheet and compare them with the signatures of the electors as they appear in the registration records of the office. If any of the randomly selected signatures do not appear to be genuine, all signatures on that sheet must be compared with the signatures in the registration records of the office.

Restrictions on petition circulators

Residency requirements for petition circulators

The Montana state legislature passed Montana Senate Bill 96 in 2007 making it illegal to pay circulators by the signature.

As of 2007, Montana also has a residency requirement for circulators. Petition circulators are required to be Montana residents. Residency is defined as: "the union of act and intent" to reside and continue to reside in Montana.

Also while Election Administrators, Clerks and Recorders previously were allowed to gather signatures on an issue, they now only will be keeping ballots for review. Here is the law that was recently passed and will be enacted in 2007:

13-27-102. Who may petition and gather signatures

  1. A petition for the initiative, the referendum, or to call a constitutional convention may be signed only by a qualified elector of the state of Montana.
  2. A person gathering signatures for the initiative, the referendum, or to call a constitutional convention:
  • must be a resident, AS PROVIDED IN 1-1-215, of the state of Montana;and
  • may not be paid anything of value based on the number of signatures gathered.[3]

See also

Single-subject restriction

Montana does have a single-subject rule for initiatives.

Legislative tampering

Main article: Legislative tampering

The Montana State Legislature can both repeal and amend initiated state statutes (but not initiated constitutional amendments, except through the normal procedures for amending the Montana Constitution.)

General comments

Once an initiative has qualified to appear on the ballot, committees are formed to write arguments for and against the issue. These arguments appear in the Voter Information Pamphlet (2006 example) that is distributed before each election to all households with a Montana voter. A three-member committee supporting the issue is appointed by the sponsor who submitted the petition. A five-member committee opposing the issue is appointed by the governor, Attorney General, president of the senate and speaker of the house of representatives. The four appointed persons appoint the fifth member.

See also

External links


  1. Review of proposed ballot issue and statements by attorney general -- preparation of fiscal note.
  2. Montana Code Annotated 2007
  3. Pay Per Signatures Blog