Difference between revisions of "Ohio Measure 3, Casino Gambling (2006)"

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Text replace - "language that appeared on the ballot:<ref" to "language appeared on the ballot as:<ref")
 
(25 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Gambling}}{{tnr}}'''Ohio Ballot Measure 3''', also known as the '''Gambling and College Scholarships - Learn and Earn Act''', was on the [[Ohio 2006 ballot measures|November 7, 2006]] election ballot in [[Ohio]].  It was defeated, with 43.1% of voters in favor.
+
<table style="float: right;">
 +
<tr valign="top">
 +
<td>
 +
{{tnr}}
 +
</td>
 +
<td>
 +
{{Gambling}}
 +
{{OHConstitution}}
 +
</td>
 +
</tr>
 +
</table>The '''Ohio Casino Gambling Amendment''', also known as '''Issue 3''', was on the [[Ohio 2006 ballot measures|November 7, 2006 ballot]] in [[Ohio]] as an {{icafull}}, where it was '''defeated'''.<ref name="statelist">[http://www.sos.state.oh.us/sos/elections/Research/electResultsMain/2006ElectionsResults.aspx ''Ohio Secretary of State'', "2006 Official Election Results," accessed July 30, 2013]</ref> This amendment would have permitted up to 31,500 slot machines at seven horse racing tracks in the state, as well as at two non-track locations in Cleveland.
  
* Yes: 1,753,452
+
==Election results==
* No: 2,286,840 {{approved}}
+
{{Short outcome
 +
|title= Ohio Issue 3 (2006)
 +
|yes=1,753,452
 +
|yespct=43.40
 +
|no=2,286,840
 +
|nopct=56.60
 +
}}
 +
Election results via the [[Ohio Secretary of State]].<ref>[http://www.sos.state.oh.us/sos/upload/elections/historical/issuehist.pdf ''Ohio Secretary of State'', "A History of Statewide Issue Votes in Ohio," accessed July 30, 2013]</ref>
  
==Text of the proposal==
+
==Text of measure==
The language that appeared on the ballot:
+
:: ''See also: [[Article XV, Ohio Constitution|Ohio Constitution, Article XV]]''
  
 +
The language appeared on the ballot as:<ref name="voterguide">[http://www.sos.state.oh.us/sos/upload/elections/2006/gen/IssuesReport_2006.pdf ''Ohio Issues Report'', "State Issues Ballot Information for the November 7, 2006 General Election," accessed July 30, 2013]</ref>
 +
{{Quote|<center>PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO THE OHIO CONSTITUTION<br>
 +
(Proposed by Initiative Petition)</center>
 +
<p>To adopt Section 12 of Article XV of the Constitution of the State of Ohio.</p>
 
This amendment to the Constitution would:
 
This amendment to the Constitution would:
 +
* Permit up to 31,500 slot machines at seven horse racing tracks and at two Cleveland non-track locations. Permit expanded gaming in the four Cuyahoga County locations if approved by the county's voters.
 +
* Distribute the revenues as follows:
 +
** 55% to the slot and casino owners and operators.
 +
** 30% to the Board of Regents for college scholarships and grants to eligible students and administration of the program.
 +
** The remaining revenues to be divided among local governments, race tracks for purse money, gambling addiction services, and
 +
** The administration of the Gaming Integrity Commission comprised of five members appointed by the governor and the majority legislative leaders.
 +
* The moneys provided by this amendment are to supplement and not supplant existing and future constitutional obligations to post-secondary education and local governments.
 +
<center>A majority yes vote is necessary for passage.</center>
 +
Shall the proposed amendment be adopted?
 +
}}
  
- Permit up to 31,500 slot machines at seven horse racing tracks and at two Cleveland non-track locations. Permit expanded gaming in the four Cuyahoga County locations if approved by the county's voters.
+
==Support==
 +
===Arguments in favor===
 +
The following reasons were given in support of Issue 3 by the ''Ohio Learn and Earn Committee'':<ref name="voterguide"/>
 +
{{Quote|A “yes” vote on Issue 3 would provide thousands of Ohio’s hard-working high school students with scholarships to Ohio’s colleges and universities. All students will be eligible to earn these scholarships, which would be funded from the proceeds of expanded gambling—slot machines—at the seven commercial horse racing tracks, and at two carefully specified locations in Cleveland’s entertainment district. Issue 3 would also provide new funds for economic development and job creation for communities throughout Ohio.
 +
<p>Unlike the proceeds from the lottery, Learn and Earn scholarship funds would be free from control of politicians who now simply reduce education’s general revenue funds by the amount of lottery proceeds. Issue 3 expressly prohibits the reduction of such funds by providing that the money generated for scholarships and local communities’ economic development will supplement, not supplant, monies currently appropriated for these purposes. The scholarship monies will be placed in individual accounts for Ohio’s primary and secondary school students under the direct control of the Ohio Board of Regents. The legislature will be powerless to divert this money for politicians’ pet projects.</p>
 +
Under Issue 3, the locations and number of slot machines would be strictly limited, and would be regulated by the new Gaming Integrity Commission, which will operate without general revenue tax dollars.
 +
<p>Each year, Ohioans spend billions of dollars on gaming entertainment in neighboring states and Canada. This amendment will help keep that money in Ohio for the benefit of Ohio and its children. Money now spent by Ohioans on gaming in Indiana, Michigan, West Virginia, and Canada (and soon, Pennsylvania), benefits the residents of those places. The money spent by Ohioans on this form of entertainment should benefit Ohioans, not out-of-state interests.</p>
 +
Vote Yes for Ohio’s Children. Vote yes on Issue 3.}}
 +
The official ballot argument in support of Issue 3 was signed by J. Gregg Haught, David L. Hopcraft and Linda J. Siefkas.
  
- Distribute the revenues as follows:
+
===Campaign contributions===
  
-- 55% to the slot and casino owners and operators.
+
The top donors to the "Yes on 3" committee were:<ref>[http://www.followthemoney.org/database/StateGlance/committee.phtml?c=2098 ''Followthemoney.org'', "Donors to and against Measure 3," accessed July 30, 2013]</ref>
 
+
-- 30% to the Board of Regents for college scholarships and grants to eligible students and administration of the program.
+
 
+
-- The remaining revenues to be divided among local governments, race tracks for purse money, gambling addiction services, and
+
 
+
-- The administration of the Gaming Integrity Commission comprised of five members appointed by the governor and the majority legislative leaders.
+
 
+
The moneys provided by this amendment are to supplement and not supplant existing and future constitutional obligations to post-secondary education and local governments.
+
 
+
A majority yes vote is necessary for passage.<Ref>[http://www.ncsl.org/programs/legismgt/elect/dbintro.htm National Conference of State Legislatures Ballot Measures Database]</ref>
+
 
+
 
+
==Donors pro and con==
+
A total of '''$28.4 million''' was spent pro and con on Measure 3, with nearly all of that ($27.2 million) coming from the unsuccessful pro-committee.
+
 
+
===Yes on 3===
+
The top donors to the "Yes on 3" committee were:
+
  
 
* The Ohio Legacy Fund, $3.5 million.
 
* The Ohio Legacy Fund, $3.5 million.
Line 41: Line 63:
 
* Riverdown Race Track, $2.6 million.
 
* Riverdown Race Track, $2.6 million.
 
* Thistledown, $2.6 million.
 
* Thistledown, $2.6 million.
* Northfield Park, $1.2 million.<ref>[http://www.followthemoney.org/database/StateGlance/committee.phtml?c=2098 Donors to and against Measure 3]</ref>
+
* Northfield Park, $1.2 million.
+
 
===Vote No to Slots===
+
==Opposition==
The top donors to the opposition campaign were:
+
===Arguments against===
 +
The following reasons were given in opposition of Issue 3 by the ''Vote NO Casinos Committee'':<ref name="voterguide"/>
 +
{{Quote|Please Vote NO on the Learn and Earn Casino Gambling Amendment. This dishonest plan, filled with loopholes, will not deliver the benefits promised. A handful of casino developers want to use your Constitution for their personal gain, but it will ruin lives.
 +
<p>Why so many are voting NO on Issue 3:</p>
 +
* Learn and Earn Casinos will create at least '''109,000 NEW gambling addicts''', ruining the lives of hundreds of thousands of families.
 +
* '''Remember the Lottery?''' It didn’t save Ohio public schools. Learn and Earn Casinos are a bad deal for students, parents, and colleges.
 +
* Learn and Earn creates '''a private monopoly''' for a handful of casino owners. Gambling proceeds are exempted from state and local taxes.
 +
* Learn and Earn Casinos '''will place NO money in the Ohio General Revenue Fund- not one dollar for the State Treasury.'''
 +
* Issue 3 will not stop Ohioans from traveling to gamble but '''will grant licenses to out-of state operators and drain more dollars from Ohio.'''
 +
* Ohio casinos will drain '''$2 billion from the local economy costing Ohio jobs.'''
 +
* Learn and Earn '''LOOPHOLES''' will leave thousands of students without scholarships. There are no guarantees on how much scholarships will be worth or when they will be paid. Only the top 5% of students will qualify for tuition grants which disappear after 12 years.
 +
* Learn and Earn will push Ohio into a Class III gambling state '''making it easier for tribal casinos to open in Ohio.'''
 +
* '''Community leaders, elected officials and many Ohio newspapers are urging a “NO” vote on Learn and Earn’s gambling casinos.'''
 +
Don’t gamble away Ohio’s future. Protect Ohio’s families and children.
 +
<p>Vote NO on ISSUE 3.</p>}}
 +
The official ballot argument in opposition of Issue 3 was signed by Betty Montgomery and David Zanotti.
 +
 
 +
===Campaign contributions===
 +
The top donors to the opposition campaign were:<ref>[http://www.followthemoney.org/database/StateGlance/committee.phtml?c=2098 ''Followthemoney.org'', "Donors to and against Measure 3," accessed July 30, 2013]</ref>
  
 
* Carl Linder, $500,000.
 
* Carl Linder, $500,000.
Line 50: Line 90:
 
* Nork, Inc. $100,000.
 
* Nork, Inc. $100,000.
 
* Nationwide Mutual Insurance, $100,000.
 
* Nationwide Mutual Insurance, $100,000.
 +
 +
==See also==
 +
{{submit a link}}
 +
* [[Ohio 2006 ballot measures]]
 +
* [[2006 ballot measures]]
 +
* [[List of Ohio ballot measures]]
 +
* [[List of ballot measures by year]]
 +
* [[List of ballot measures by state]]
 +
 +
==External links==
 +
* [http://www.sos.state.oh.us/SOS/elections/Research/electResultsMain.aspx Ohio ballot measures and election results]
 +
* [http://www.sos.state.oh.us/sos/upload/elections/historical/issuehist.pdf A History of Statewide Issue Votes in Ohio]
 +
* [http://www.sos.state.oh.us/sos/upload/elections/2006/gen/IssuesReport_2006.pdf Ohio 2006 ballot measure voter's guide]
  
 
==References==
 
==References==
<references/>
+
{{reflist}}
  
{{Ohio}}
+
{{2006 ballot measures}}
 +
{{ohio}}
  
 
[[Category:Ohio 2006 ballot measures]]
 
[[Category:Ohio 2006 ballot measures]]
 
[[Category:Gambling, Ohio]]
 
[[Category:Gambling, Ohio]]
 +
[[Category:Gambling, 2006]]

Latest revision as of 15:30, 6 March 2014

Voting on Gambling
Roulette.jpg
Ballot Measures
By state
By year
Not on ballot
Local Measures
Ohio Constitution
Seal of Ohio.svg.png
Preamble
Articles
IIIIIIIVVVIVIIVIIIIXXXIXIIXIIIXIVXVXVIXVIIXVIIISchedule
The Ohio Casino Gambling Amendment, also known as Issue 3, was on the November 7, 2006 ballot in Ohio as an initiated constitutional amendment, where it was defeated.[1] This amendment would have permitted up to 31,500 slot machines at seven horse racing tracks in the state, as well as at two non-track locations in Cleveland.

Election results

Ohio Issue 3 (2006)
ResultVotesPercentage
Defeatedd No2,286,84056.60%
Yes 1,753,452 43.40%

Election results via the Ohio Secretary of State.[2]

Text of measure

See also: Ohio Constitution, Article XV

The language appeared on the ballot as:[3]

PROPOSED AMENDMENT TO THE OHIO CONSTITUTION
(Proposed by Initiative Petition)

To adopt Section 12 of Article XV of the Constitution of the State of Ohio.

This amendment to the Constitution would:

  • Permit up to 31,500 slot machines at seven horse racing tracks and at two Cleveland non-track locations. Permit expanded gaming in the four Cuyahoga County locations if approved by the county's voters.
  • Distribute the revenues as follows:
    • 55% to the slot and casino owners and operators.
    • 30% to the Board of Regents for college scholarships and grants to eligible students and administration of the program.
    • The remaining revenues to be divided among local governments, race tracks for purse money, gambling addiction services, and
    • The administration of the Gaming Integrity Commission comprised of five members appointed by the governor and the majority legislative leaders.
  • The moneys provided by this amendment are to supplement and not supplant existing and future constitutional obligations to post-secondary education and local governments.
A majority yes vote is necessary for passage.

Shall the proposed amendment be adopted? [4]

Support

Arguments in favor

The following reasons were given in support of Issue 3 by the Ohio Learn and Earn Committee:[3]

A “yes” vote on Issue 3 would provide thousands of Ohio’s hard-working high school students with scholarships to Ohio’s colleges and universities. All students will be eligible to earn these scholarships, which would be funded from the proceeds of expanded gambling—slot machines—at the seven commercial horse racing tracks, and at two carefully specified locations in Cleveland’s entertainment district. Issue 3 would also provide new funds for economic development and job creation for communities throughout Ohio.

Unlike the proceeds from the lottery, Learn and Earn scholarship funds would be free from control of politicians who now simply reduce education’s general revenue funds by the amount of lottery proceeds. Issue 3 expressly prohibits the reduction of such funds by providing that the money generated for scholarships and local communities’ economic development will supplement, not supplant, monies currently appropriated for these purposes. The scholarship monies will be placed in individual accounts for Ohio’s primary and secondary school students under the direct control of the Ohio Board of Regents. The legislature will be powerless to divert this money for politicians’ pet projects.

Under Issue 3, the locations and number of slot machines would be strictly limited, and would be regulated by the new Gaming Integrity Commission, which will operate without general revenue tax dollars.

Each year, Ohioans spend billions of dollars on gaming entertainment in neighboring states and Canada. This amendment will help keep that money in Ohio for the benefit of Ohio and its children. Money now spent by Ohioans on gaming in Indiana, Michigan, West Virginia, and Canada (and soon, Pennsylvania), benefits the residents of those places. The money spent by Ohioans on this form of entertainment should benefit Ohioans, not out-of-state interests.

Vote Yes for Ohio’s Children. Vote yes on Issue 3.[4]

The official ballot argument in support of Issue 3 was signed by J. Gregg Haught, David L. Hopcraft and Linda J. Siefkas.

Campaign contributions

The top donors to the "Yes on 3" committee were:[5]

  • The Ohio Legacy Fund, $3.5 million.
  • Jacobs Entertainment, $2.9 million.
  • Forest City Enterprises, $2.8 million.
  • MTR Gaming Group, $2.7 million.
  • Delaware North Gaming, $2.6 million.
  • Heartland Jockey Club, $2.6 million.
  • Penn National Gaming, $2.6 million.
  • Riverdown Race Track, $2.6 million.
  • Thistledown, $2.6 million.
  • Northfield Park, $1.2 million.

Opposition

Arguments against

The following reasons were given in opposition of Issue 3 by the Vote NO Casinos Committee:[3]

Please Vote NO on the Learn and Earn Casino Gambling Amendment. This dishonest plan, filled with loopholes, will not deliver the benefits promised. A handful of casino developers want to use your Constitution for their personal gain, but it will ruin lives.

Why so many are voting NO on Issue 3:

  • Learn and Earn Casinos will create at least 109,000 NEW gambling addicts, ruining the lives of hundreds of thousands of families.
  • Remember the Lottery? It didn’t save Ohio public schools. Learn and Earn Casinos are a bad deal for students, parents, and colleges.
  • Learn and Earn creates a private monopoly for a handful of casino owners. Gambling proceeds are exempted from state and local taxes.
  • Learn and Earn Casinos will place NO money in the Ohio General Revenue Fund- not one dollar for the State Treasury.
  • Issue 3 will not stop Ohioans from traveling to gamble but will grant licenses to out-of state operators and drain more dollars from Ohio.
  • Ohio casinos will drain $2 billion from the local economy costing Ohio jobs.
  • Learn and Earn LOOPHOLES will leave thousands of students without scholarships. There are no guarantees on how much scholarships will be worth or when they will be paid. Only the top 5% of students will qualify for tuition grants which disappear after 12 years.
  • Learn and Earn will push Ohio into a Class III gambling state making it easier for tribal casinos to open in Ohio.
  • Community leaders, elected officials and many Ohio newspapers are urging a “NO” vote on Learn and Earn’s gambling casinos.

Don’t gamble away Ohio’s future. Protect Ohio’s families and children.

Vote NO on ISSUE 3.

[4]

The official ballot argument in opposition of Issue 3 was signed by Betty Montgomery and David Zanotti.

Campaign contributions

The top donors to the opposition campaign were:[6]

  • Carl Linder, $500,000.
  • Wolfe Enterprises, $150,000.
  • Nork, Inc. $100,000.
  • Nationwide Mutual Insurance, $100,000.

See also

BallotpediaAvatar bigger.png
Suggest a link

External links

References