Difference between revisions of "Recall"

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 42: Line 42:
  
 
==Statewide recall==
 
==Statewide recall==
Currently, nineteen states permit the recall of state officials.<ref name=ncsl/>  These are: [[Laws governing recall in Alaska|Alaska]], [[Laws governing recall in Arizona|Arizona]], [[Laws governing recall in California|California]], [[Laws governing recall in Colorado|Colorado]], [[Laws governing recall in Georgia|Georgia]], [[Laws governing recall in Idaho|Idaho]], [[Laws governing recall in Kansas|Kansas]], [[Laws governing recall in Louisiana|Louisiana]], [[Laws governing recall in Michigan|Michigan]], [[Laws governing recall in Minnesota|Minnesota]], [[Laws governing recall in Montana|Montana]], [[Laws governing recall in Nevada|Nevada]], [[Laws governing recall in New Jersey|New Jersey]], [[Laws governing recall in North Dakota|North Dakota]], [[Laws governing recall in Oregon|Oregon]], [[Laws governing recall in Rhode Island|Rhode Island]], [[Laws governing recall in Washington|Washington]], and [[Laws governing recall in Wisconsin|Wisconsin]].
+
Currently, nineteen states permit the recall of state officials.<ref name=ncsl/>  The states that permit  [[Laws governing recall in Alaska|Alaska]], [[Laws governing recall in Arizona|Arizona]], [[Laws governing recall in California|California]], [[Laws governing recall in Colorado|Colorado]], [[Laws governing recall in Georgia|Georgia]], [[Laws governing recall in Idaho|Idaho]], [[Laws governing recall in Illinois|Illinois]], [[Laws governing recall in Kansas|Kansas]], [[Laws governing recall in Louisiana|Louisiana]], [[Laws governing recall in Michigan|Michigan]], [[Laws governing recall in Minnesota|Minnesota]], [[Laws governing recall in Montana|Montana]], [[Laws governing recall in Nevada|Nevada]], [[Laws governing recall in New Jersey|New Jersey]], [[Laws governing recall in North Dakota|North Dakota]], [[Laws governing recall in Oregon|Oregon]], [[Laws governing recall in Rhode Island|Rhode Island]], [[Laws governing recall in Washington|Washington]], and [[Laws governing recall in Wisconsin|Wisconsin]].
 +
 
 +
===Officials eligible by state===
 +
Many states allow for the recall of all elected officials, while others only allow for recall in limited cases.
 +
 
 +
[[<onlyinclude><imagemap>
 +
Image:Recall_who_2013.png|650px
 +
 
 +
poly 43 81 34 109 67 152 82 90 [[Nevada]]
 +
rect 33 208 77 253 [[Alaska]]
 +
rect 132 239 179 279 [[Hawaii]]
 +
poly 75 141 63 185 90 202 106 205 112 149 [[Arizona]]
 +
poly 84 88 74 137 114 145 118 106 103 103 104 91 [[Utah]]
 +
poly 115 150 109 205 158 201 161 154 [[New Mexico]]
 +
poly 121 107 115 144 169 149 172 112 [[Colorado]]
 +
poly 112 62 105 100 157 107 159 66 [[Wyoming]]
 +
poly 12 72 10 123 17 152 41 179 58 181 63 160 30 110 37 80 [[California]]
 +
poly 26 37 12 67 58 79 67 48 [[Oregon]]
 +
poly 32 11 29 25 70 39 75 15 46 6 [[Washington]]
 +
poly 80 13 65 81 103 88 108 68 86 60 84 14 [[Idaho]]
 +
poly 87 16 96 58 160 64 164 27 [[Montana]]
 +
poly 168 26 165 55 216 57 212 27 [[North Dakota]]
 +
poly 165 58 162 86 216 89 215 61 [[South Dakota]]
 +
poly 162 89 160 106 175 108 175 120 226 120 216 93 [[Nebraska]]
 +
poly 176 123 174 150 235 152 235 130 230 123 [[Kansas]]
 +
poly 165 152 165 156 192 157 190 178 235 186 235 155 [[Oklahoma]]
 +
poly 165 158 163 205 131 203 171 227 205 263 242 229 240 191 188 180 188 160 [[Texas]]
 +
poly 216 27 221 81 259 82 244 61 262 36 [[Minnesota]]
 +
poly 220 85 226 113 259 113 266 99 259 86 [[Iowa]]
 +
poly 229 116 237 130 238 155 279 152 257 116 [[Missouri]]
 +
poly 237 159 243 191 265 191 272 161 [[Arkansas]]
 +
poly 245 197 248 225 279 230 278 218 260 215 264 197 [[Louisiana]]
 +
poly 264 213 282 213 285 221 293 218 290 172 274 174 [[Mississippi]]
 +
poly 293 173 296 217 301 211 321 208 312 170  [[Alabama]]
 +
poly 254 50 248 65 265 90 283 88 285 66 [[Wisconsin]]
 +
poly 271 94 262 117 282 146 292 131 289 94 [[Illinois]]
 +
poly 279 157 278 170 322 165 343 148 [[Tennessee]]
 +
poly 283 154 293 143 316 130 335 137 327 146 [[Kentucky]]
 +
poly 293 137 294 101 310 98 314 125 [[Indiana]]
 +
poly 276 46 301 95 319 93 324 74 303 49 [[Michigan]]
 +
poly 313 97 317 121 333 125 345 103 341 92 [[Ohio]]
 +
poly 316 170 326 208 352 206 353 193 331 169 [[Georgia]]
 +
poly 301 212 331 220 364 261 372 254 354 211 [[Florida]]
 +
poly 336 166 357 189 371 170 [[South Carolina]]
 +
poly 329 163 373 162 390 143 346 149 [[North Carolina]]
 +
poly 344 143 369 117 387 133 [[Virginia]]
 +
poly 336 131 346 113 361 115 347 136 [[West Virginia]]
 +
poly 346 89 349 109 385 101 384 83 [[Pennsylvania]]
 +
poly 353 74 351 85 383 81 394 88 385 49 370 68 [[New York]]
 +
circle 335 35 5 [[Vermont]]
 +
poly 388 49 395 66 396 48 [[Vermont]]
 +
circle 368 36 5 [[New Hampshire]]
 +
poly 401 47 400 64 408 62 [[New Hampshire]]
 +
circle 442 55 5 [[Massachusetts]]
 +
poly 394 69 395 75 415 70 412 65 [[Massachusetts]]
 +
circle 437 78 5 [[Rhode Island]]
 +
poly 407 75 410 80 412 76 [[Rhode Island]]
 +
circle 419 120 5 [[Connecticut]]
 +
poly 395 77 396 84 407 81 407 75 [[Connecticut]]
 +
circle 420 98 5 [[New Jersey]]
 +
poly 388 87 388 102 393 106 397 94 [[New Jersey]]
 +
circle 420 140 5 [[Delaware]]
 +
poly 385 104 387 115 393 114 [[Delaware]]
 +
circle 420 161 5 [[Maryland]]
 +
poly 368 108 387 121 384 106 [[Maryland]]
 +
poly 403 41 410 55 427 36 416 15 405 16 [[Maine]]
 +
 
 +
desc none
 +
</imagemap></onlyinclude>|thumb|right|320px|The 50 states vary in the offices that may be subject to recall elections.]]
 +
 
  
 
==Recalls by type of political office==
 
==Recalls by type of political office==

Revision as of 00:22, 27 June 2013

Recall campaigns by year
20132012201120102009200820072006
20052003200219991996
19951994199319921988
19841983197819671952
1949193219241921
1916191419131911
Recall news
Recall laws
Recall is a process available in most jurisdictions whereby an elected official can be removed from office either for malfeasance or in some jurisdictions for any action the recall language specifies. For recalls, most state laws have set the highest signature threshold for any type of petition - most often requiring 25% of all registered voters or 25% of voters in the last election for the recalled office to sign a recall petition.

Notable recalls

Gubernatorial recalls

Only three United States governors have faced recall elections. Two of them (Lynn Frazier, 1921 and Gray Davis, 2003) were consequently removed from office while the other (Scott Walker, 2012) retained his seat.[1][2][3]

Wisconsin, 2012

Shortly after taking office in 2011, Republican Governor Scott Walker of Wisconsin proposed legislation (Wisconsin Act 10, known as the "Scott Walker Budget Repair Bill") that restricted public workers' collective bargaining abilities.[4] The proposal sparked massive protests statewide, most notably in downtown Madison, as unionized workers gathered to resist the measure.[3]

The bill's opponents targeted Walker for recall, successfully forcing him to face a recall election on June 5, 2012.[5] He ran against Democrat Tom Barrett, whom he had previously faced in the general election, and defeated him 53% to 46%. He became the first governor to survive a recall.[3]

The legislation also triggered several recalls of State Senators. See below for a list of other Wisconsin officials recalled in the 2012 conflict.[3]

California, 2003

The most recent successful recall was that of Democratic Governor Gray Davis of California in 2003.[2]

Davis, first elected in 1998, enjoyed popularity for much of his first term, maintaining a 58% approval rating and 12% disapproval rating.[6] Then in May 2001, in the midst of the California electricity crisis, his numbers began slipping—only to be further aggravated by his middle-of-the-road approach to politics, such that by October 2003 his approval rating was only 27%.[7]

Davis was defeated by Arnold Schwarzenegger in the special election held on October 7, 2003.[2] He said in his concession speech,

We've had a lot of good nights over the last 20 years, but tonight the people did decide it is time for someone else to serve, and I accept their judgment.[2][8]

North Dakota, 1921

Though a popular governor throughout his first two terms (spanning 1917 to 1920), Republican (Nonpartisan League) Governor Lynn Frazier met political dissonance upon his third election. Economic trouble in North Dakota following poor farming seasons and World War I led to conflict between political forces, especially in light of the newly established Industrial Commission, put in place to oversee state-owned industries.[9]

The state constitution had recently been amended to provide for the recall of public officials, and was immediately used to recall Frazier and the other officials that comprised the Industrial Commission.[9]

Other recalls

  • In 1983, two Democratic State Senators were recalled in Michigan shortly following the election of Governor James Blanchard, who upon taking office earlier that year promised to raise taxes. The State Senator switched hands into Republican control, and no tax increase occurred.
  • In Michigan, Leon Drolet, former Michigan State Representative (2001 - 2007) and Macomb County Commissioner (2007 - ?), formed a group called the Michigan Taxpayers Alliance which has referred to Michigan's 1983 history with a button "Recall 1983." Drolet has threatened to recall any legislator who votes yes on tax increases in Michigan and has received considerable media attention as a result. Drolet is also known for co-chairing the Michigan Civil Rights Amendment, Proposal 2 (2006) (MCRI) Committee, which successfully passed Michigan's Proposal 2 of 2006, ending race and gender-based types of affirmative action in government hiring, education, and contracting.
  • A recall proceeding is underway in Washington State in regard to Thurston County Commissioners Wolfe, Valenzuela and Romero, for alleged illegal expenditures of public funds to a private "Shadow Government" agency, the Washington State Association of Counties.

Statewide recall

Currently, nineteen states permit the recall of state officials.[10] The states that permit Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Kansas, Louisiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, New Jersey, North Dakota, Oregon, Rhode Island, Washington, and Wisconsin.

Officials eligible by state

Many states allow for the recall of all elected officials, while others only allow for recall in limited cases.

[[
NevadaAlaskaHawaiiArizonaUtahNew MexicoColoradoWyomingCaliforniaOregonWashingtonIdahoMontanaNorth DakotaSouth DakotaNebraskaKansasOklahomaTexasMinnesotaIowaMissouriArkansasLouisianaMississippiAlabamaWisconsinIllinoisTennesseeKentuckyIndianaMichiganOhioGeorgiaFloridaSouth CarolinaNorth CarolinaVirginiaWest VirginiaPennsylvaniaNew YorkVermontVermontNew HampshireNew HampshireMassachusettsMassachusettsRhode IslandRhode IslandConnecticutConnecticutNew JerseyNew JerseyDelawareDelawareMarylandMarylandMaineRecall who 2013.png
|thumb|right|320px|The 50 states vary in the offices that may be subject to recall elections.]]


Recalls by type of political office

See also

References