The Tuesday Count: Low number of initiatives on 2013 ballots
Edited by Brittany Clingenstatewide ballots are officially set in six states - Colorado, Maine, New Jersey, New York, Texas and Washington - for the general election on November 5, 2013. Going forward throughout the weeks preceding the election, Ballotpedia's Tuesday Count will be providing various reports and analyses of the measures that will appear on the ballot. For ongoing pre-election coverage, please see here.
2013 initiative activity
In total, there are 26 states with some form of direct democracy. This year, for all measures on the ballot, a total of two initiative and referendum states had measures up for a public vote. However, before those measures are placed on the ballot, they must be filed and proposed to their state election officials before they can circulate for signatures.
This means that some initiative efforts can fail in numerous ways - unconstitutional ballot text, shortage of valid signatures, missed deadlines, etc. For those reasons, not all measures filed make the ballot; in fact, many fail for one reason or another.
In 2013, a grand total of 133 initiatives were filed with intent to circulate for signature gathering. Of those 133 initiatives, only 3 made it on the ballot. In the findings below, we took a deeper look at the filed initiatives, those that were certified, and the a breakdown of measures that were proposed in each state. This analysis does not include legislative proposals or referrals to the ballot.
By the numbers
To accurately gauge how 2013 ballots compare to those in other years, we used 2011 and 2009 as benchmarks, as these were also odd-numbered years; ballots in odd-numbered years tend to feature fewer measures than those in even-numbered years. In 2011, 137 initiatives were filed. Though 2013 saw only four less initiatives filed than 2011 - 133 compared to 137 - certified initiatives were particularly sparse on the ballot. In 2011, five of the 26 states - Colorado, Maine, Mississippi, Ohio and Washington - had initiatives appear on the ballot. Three states - Maine, Ohio and Washington - had a total of eight initiatives on the ballot in 2009. In 2013, only two states - Colorado and Washington - feature initiatives, with those in Washington being Initiatives to the Legislature. In 2011, 12 out of 137 filed initiatives were certified for the ballot, making the certification rate approximately nine percent. In 2013, only 3 out of 133 filed initiatives were certified, yielding a certification rate of just over two percent.
No signatures submitted
In 2013, neither Washington nor Ohio saw any petition signatures submitted by the filing deadlines in early July. There is no limit on how long petitions may be circulated in Ohio. Therefore, supporters of citizen-initiated amendments being circulated for the 2013 ballot can continue collecting signatures in an effort to put the measures before voters in 2014.
|States:||Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, California, Connecticut, Louisiana, Michigan, Montana Nevada, New York, Tennessee, Texas and Wyoming|
However, this is not the case in Washington, meaning that all 85 initiatives filed with the Secretary of State are dead in the water. This is surprising, given that Washington ballots have not been void of Initiatives to the People since 1989. In 2012, a total of 79 initiatives to the people were filed with the Secretary of State, though only two were ultimately certified for the ballot. A wide variety of topics were addressed across the 85 potential 2013 measures, including education, government fraud, the death penalty and taxpayer protection. All of the initiatives needed at least 246,372 valid signatures to appear on the ballot. The two Initiatives to the Legislature which are on the Washington 2013 ballot go through a different process than that of Initiatives to the People. First an Initiative to the Legislature must be certified. Once that occurs, the measure is sent to the legislature. If nothing is done there, then the measure goes to a vote of the people.
|# of initiatives proposed||# initiatives certified in 2013||% certified|
Outcome - certified initiatives
NOTE: The chart below specifically details the number of proposed initiatives per state and the number/percentage of successfully certified initiatives for 2013 ballots.
|I&R State||# of initiatives proposed||# initiatives certified in 2013||% certified|
Lawsuit could change measure wording of Proposal 1 in New York: On October 1, 2013, lawyer Eric J. Snyder filed a brief against the New York Board of Elections with the New York Supreme Court related to the measure wording controversy. Snyder is asking the court to order a rewriting of the language or a removal of the measure from the ballot. He citied a recent poll comparing a generalized question on authorizing casino gambling and the specific ballot question as evidence of biased wording. A number of newspapers have also called for a rewording. On October 11, Judge Richard Platkin heard the lawsuit. He will be deciding whether the case is to be dismissed or moved forward sometime this week.
A local pension reform measure in Hialeah, Florida, has gone largely unnoticed by the news or unions:
"Revising Pension Article to require voter approval of future changes to elected officials pension"
Shall the City amend the pension provisions of the Hialeah Charter to require Hialeah voters to approve any future changes to the pension plan for elected officials, which will be closed to new elected officials beginning on January 1,2014?
This measure was referred to the ballot by the Hialeah City Counicl and has largely flown under the radar, without either a lot of news coverage or active opposition or support campaigns.
| 2013 ballot measures|
|Tuesday Count • 2013 Scorecard|
- Ballotpedia's Tuesday Count for 2013
- 2013 ballot measures & 2014
- Local ballot measure elections in 2013
- Potential 2013 ballot measures & 2014
- Merced County November 5, 2013 ballot measures
- Note: This text is quoted verbatim from the original source. Any inconsistencies are attributed to the original source.
- The agenda of the city council meeting referring the question to the ballot