Everything you need to know about ranked-choice voting in one spot. Click to learn more!

North Carolina Supreme Court elections, 2016

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Ballotpedia Election Coverage Badge-smaller use.png

Presidential • U.S. Senate • U.S. House • Governor • Lt. Gov • Attorney General • Secretary of State • State executive offices • State Senate • State House • State judges • Local judges • State ballot measures • School boards • Municipal • Recalls • Candidate ballot access
Flag of North Carolina.png
2016 State
Judicial Elections
Ballotpedia Election Coverage Badge.png
Part 1: Overview
Part 2: Supreme Courts
Part 3: Partisanship
Part 4: Changes in 2016

One seat on the North Carolina Supreme Court was up for nonpartisan election on November 8, 2016. A primary was held on June 7. This seat was held by Justice Robert H. Edmunds Jr. heading into the election. Justice Edmunds ran to remain in his seat after a court battle that overturned North Carolina's 2015 retention election law, under which Justice Edmunds would have faced only a yes-no retention vote, rather than an opponent in a contested election. Challenger Judge Michael R. Morgan advanced through the primary along with Justice Edmunds. The two faced each other on November 8.

A justice on the North Carolina Supreme Court serves an eight-year term. North Carolina judicial elections are nonpartisan; the top two candidates in a primary advance to the general election, regardless of party. Republican-affiliated justices held a 4-3 majority heading into the 2016 election.

HIGHLIGHTS
  • Robert H. Edmunds Jr. was defeated by challenger Judge Michael R. Morgan.
  • North Carolina Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Edmunds Jr. was to have faced the first retention election in North Carolina. However, a North Carolina court struck down the retention election law as unconstitutional; a divided state supreme court (3-3) upheld this ruling.
  • The election and office are nonpartisan, but North Carolina state supreme court justices often have known political party affiliations.
  • Going into the election, Republican-affiliated justices held a 4-3 majority on the court. With Edmunds defeated, the balance of the court shifted to 4-3 in favor of Democratic-affiliated justices.
  • This election was one of Ballotpedia's top 10 state-level races in 2016.
    Click here to read the full list.

    Race background

    North Carolina judicial elections are nonpartisan, but this does not mean no information is available about candidates' political affiliation. Rather, it means that when a primary election is held, it does not winnow down the candidates to one from each party; it winnows down the candidates to two for each seat, regardless of party. In North Carolina's supreme court elections, candidates do not declare their party affiliations and those party affiliations do not appear on the ballot, but their party affiliations are known from political associations and/or previous partisan elections.

    In June 2015, Gov. Pat McCrory (R) signed into law a bill requiring sitting justices on the North Carolina Supreme Court to seek re-election in retention elections rather than in nonpartisan competitive elections, effective in 2016. The law specified that for a sitting justice to be re-elected, he or she must receive at least 50 percent "yes" votes in yes-no retention elections.[1]

    Justice Robert Edmunds was the only supreme court justice up for re-election in 2016. He filed to stand for retention by voters.

    In March 2016, however, a three-judge panel of Wake County Superior Court judges ruled the retention law unconstitutional, stating that "a retention election is not an 'election' for the office of supreme court justice as required by the constitution."[2][3]

    The state appealed the ruling to the North Carolina Supreme Court.[4] On April 13, 2016, the court heard oral arguments on the constitutionality of the retention election law. Justice Robert Edmunds was recused from hearing the case, since he had filed to stand for retention in 2016. On May 6, the remaining justices split 3-3 on the question, and therefore the lower court's ruling to overturn the law was upheld.[5]

    Three challengers then filed to run in a contested election against Justice Edmunds, including attorney Sabra Faires, one of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit. Because there were more than two candidates, a primary election was required. North Carolina's regularly scheduled primary was held March 15, in the wake of the ruling striking down the retention law and before any provision could be made for a contested judicial election. The state elections board set a special primary for June 7. Justice Edmunds and challenger Judge Michael R. Morgan finished first and second, respectively, of the four candidates and went on to face each other in the November 8 general election.

    General election candidates

    Seat 2

    Edmunds Thumb.jpg Justice Robert Edmunds (Defeated)
    Most recent position: Justice, Supreme Court of North Carolina
    Past experience: Judge, North Carolina Court of Appeals
    Edmunds is considered a Republican-affiliated judge.

    Justice Edmunds: "As the only candidate with experience on the Supreme Court, my record is an open book. I enjoy bipartisan support of most of North Carolina’s leading lawyers, including four former Chief Justices, former presidents of the North Carolina State Bar and North Carolina Bar Association and almost all of North Carolina’s elected sheriffs."[6]

    Morgan Thumb.jpg Judge Michael Morgan (Winner)
    Most recent position: Superior Court Judge, 10th Judicial District, Third Division of the Superior Court, North Carolina
    Past experience: District Court Judge, North Carolina 10th Judicial District
    Morgan is considered a Democratic-affiliated judge.

    Judge Morgan: "With more than 26 years of current judicial service, 24 years of current teaching tenure at The National Judicial College instructing other judges, and a long record of community involvement and uplift, I have a unique preparation in the ability to legally analyze, assiduously study yet humanly understand the challenges of society with which the Supreme Court is presented."[6]

    Election results

    November 8 general election

    Michael R. Morgan defeated incumbent Robert H. Edmunds, Jr. in the general election for the North Carolina Supreme Court, Seat 2.
    North Carolina Supreme Court, Seat 2, 2016
    Candidate Vote % Votes
    Green check mark transparent.png Michael R. Morgan 54.47% 2,157,927
    Robert H. Edmunds, Jr. Incumbent 45.53% 1,803,425
    Total Votes (2,704 of 2,704: 100%) 3,961,352
    Source: North Carolina State Board of Elections Official Results

    June 7 primary election

    North Carolina Supreme Court Primary, Seat 2, 2016
    Candidate Vote % Votes
    Green check mark transparent.png Robert H. Edmunds, Jr. Incumbent 48.01% 235,405
    Green check mark transparent.png Michael R. Morgan 34.36% 168,498
    Sabra Jean Faires 12.04% 59,040
    Daniel G. Robertson 5.59% 27,401
    Total Votes (2710 of 2710 precincts reporting: 100%) 490,344
    Source: North Carolina State Board of Elections Official Results

    Low turnout

    Turnout in the primary election was low. One estimate placed it at about 6.65 percent, with at least one county falling below 5 percent of registered voter turnout.[7] Another estimate placed it at about 7.7 percent turnout statewide, with at least one county as high as high as 10 percent.[8] Turnout is historically low for special elections; this primary was not on the regular election schedule and was called in the wake of court decisions that required an extra primary.[7] Thus, around 7 percent of the state's registered voters chose the two November state supreme court candidates.

    Endorsements

    The candidates received the following endorsements.[9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19]

    Key endorsements
    Robert Edmunds Michael Morgan
    Gerald Arnold, Raleigh (Former Chief Judge) Indy Week
    Rhoda Billings, Lewisville (Former Chief Justice) People's Alliance PAC
    Sid Eagles, Raleigh (Former Chief Judge) Sierra Club of Western North Carolina
    Jim Exum, Greensboro (Former Chief Justice) North Carolina Advocates for Justice
    Burley Mitchell, Raleigh (Former Chief Justice) North Carolina Fraternal Order of Police
    Beverly Lake, Raleigh (Former Chief Justice) North Carolina AFL-CIO
    Sheriffs of 95 out of 100 North Carolina counties North Carolina Association of Educators
    North Carolina Governor Pat McCrory (R) Replacements Ltd. PAC
    North Carolina Conservatives Political Action Committee Bladen County Improvement Association
    Grass Roots North Carolina Durham Committee on the Affairs of Black People
    Henderson-Vance Black Leadership Caucus
    Wake County Voter Education Coalition
    Raleigh-Wake Citizens Association

    Campaign finance

    The campaign finance data below shows the candidates' contributions and expenditures up to the end of the second quarter (June 30, 2016).


    Robert Edmunds campaign finance 2016


    Michael Morgan campaign finance 2016




    BP-Initials-UPDATED.png The finance data shown here comes from the disclosures required of candidates and parties. Depending on the election or state, this may not represent all the funds spent on their behalf. Satellite spending groups may or may not have expended funds related to the candidate or politician on whose page you are reading this disclaimer, and campaign finance data from elections may be incomplete. For elections to federal offices, complete data can be found at the FEC website. Click here for more on federal campaign finance law and here for more on state campaign finance law.


    Satellite spending

    Main article: Political spending not controlled by candidates or their campaigns

    Groups unaffiliated with candidates or campaigns—such as political action committees, super PACs, nonprofit public welfare organizations, and labor unions—often spend money to influence the outcome of an election. This satellite spending can take the form of express advocacy, which encourages votes for or against a candidate, or issue advocacy, which supports broad political or social issues. Some groups are restricted on which kind of advocacy they can engage in based on their tax status.

    Disclosure regulations vary from state to state and vary based on type of organization, complicating the process of determining a comprehensive picture of all spending in a given election.

    For example, nonprofits are not always required to disclose their donors to the government; they submit financial information to the federal government through regular tax filings with the Internal Revenue Service, which are only publicly available through a Freedom of Information Act request. Other organizations are required to report election expenditures to a state elections division.

    Primary

    North Carolina Chamber of Commerce ad for Justice Edmunds

    The North Carolina Chamber of Commerce spent $450,000 before the primary running a television ad in support of Justice Edmunds.[20] The ad's premise is "keeping children safe." It alludes to Edmunds' background as a prosecutor and describes him as having "thrown the book at predators, refusing to let them use loopholes—instead, locking them up and keeping them off the internet and streets."[20][21] Funding for the ad was contributed by the Institute for Legal Reform ($250,000) and the Judicial Crisis Network ($200,000).[20]






    Ads

    Before the primary election, the North Carolina Chamber of Commerce ran a television ad (shown above) supporting Edmunds.

    Between the primary and the general elections, the Brennan Center noted ad buys of $132,280 for Morgan and $20,078 for Edmunds as of October 6.[22]

    Candidate forum

    The North Carolina Bar Association Foundation hosted a forum between Justice Edmunds and Judge Morgan. In the 20-minute video presentation, the candidates discuss their experience as judges on the bench. Justice Edmunds reiterates that his record as a justice is an open book, with most decisions available online. Judge Morgan re-emphasizes his 27 years as a lower-court judge and expresses concern about politicization on the court, including decisions that he says call into question the separation of government powers.

    NC Bar Association Foundation, "NC Supreme Court Race: Bob Edmunds vs Mike Morgan," September 8, 2016

    Political composition

    North Carolina's supreme court justices are elected in nonpartisan races. The partisan affiliations listed below are commonly attached to the justices based on voting record and past political affiliation.[23]

    The court's balance in 2016 stood at 4-3 in favor of Republican-affiliated justices. With Judge Morgan's defeat of Justice Edmunds, however, the balance shifted to 4-3 in favor of Democrat-affiliated justices.

    Button-Red.svg Chief Justice Mark Martin
    Button-Red.svg Justice Paul Martin Newby
    Button-Red.svg Justice Robert H. Edmunds Jr.
    Button-Red.svg Justice Barbara Jackson
    Button-Blue.svg Justice Robin Hudson
    Button-Blue.svg Justice Cheri Beasley
    Button-Blue.svg Justice Sam Ervin

    Selection

    See also: Judicial selection in North Carolina

    The court consists of six associate justices and one chief justice, although the number of justices has varied from time to time. Justices are chosen by nonpartisan elections to eight-year terms. If there is a vacancy in the court, a justice is chosen through the assisted appointment method of judicial selection. A justice who is appointed to a vacancy by the governor must run in an election that is at least 60 days after the vacancy occurred in order to serve a full term.[24]

    In 1989, the Judicial Selection Study Commission released a report regarding judicial selection. The commission recommended that justices be appointed to a seat on the court. However, the idea did not gain enough support in the North Carolina House of Representatives to change the process.[25]

    Qualifications

    To serve on any court in North Carolina individuals must be:

    • attorneys and
    • under the age of 72.[24][26]

    Supreme court justices in North Carolina must retire before the last day of the month in which they turn 72.[27]

    Chief justice

    The chief justice of the North Carolina Supreme Court is elected by voters for an eight-year term.[24]

    State profile

    Demographic data for North Carolina
     North CarolinaU.S.
    Total population:10,035,186316,515,021
    Land area (sq mi):48,6183,531,905
    Race and ethnicity**
    White:69.5%73.6%
    Black/African American:21.5%12.6%
    Asian:2.5%5.1%
    Native American:1.2%0.8%
    Pacific Islander:0.1%0.2%
    Two or more:2.4%3%
    Hispanic/Latino:8.8%17.1%
    Education
    High school graduation rate:85.8%86.7%
    College graduation rate:28.4%29.8%
    Income
    Median household income:$46,868$53,889
    Persons below poverty level:20.5%11.3%
    Source: U.S. Census Bureau, "American Community Survey" (5-year estimates 2010-2015)
    Click here for more information on the 2020 census and here for more on its impact on the redistricting process in North Carolina.
    **Note: Percentages for race and ethnicity may add up to more than 100 percent because respondents may report more than one race and the Hispanic/Latino ethnicity may be selected in conjunction with any race. Read more about race and ethnicity in the census here.

    Presidential voting pattern

    See also: Presidential voting trends in North Carolina

    North Carolina voted Republican in six out of the seven presidential elections between 2000 and 2024.

    Pivot Counties (2016)

    Ballotpedia identified 206 counties that voted for Donald Trump (R) in 2016 after voting for Barack Obama (D) in 2008 and 2012. Collectively, Trump won these Pivot Counties by more than 580,000 votes. Of these 206 counties, six are located in North Carolina, accounting for 2.91 percent of the total pivot counties.[28]

    Pivot Counties (2020)

    In 2020, Ballotpedia re-examined the 206 Pivot Counties to view their voting patterns following that year's presidential election. Ballotpedia defined those won by Trump won as Retained Pivot Counties and those won by Joe Biden (D) as Boomerang Pivot Counties. Nationwide, there were 181 Retained Pivot Counties and 25 Boomerang Pivot Counties. North Carolina had six Retained Pivot Counties, 3.31 percent of all Retained Pivot Counties.

    More North Carolina coverage on Ballotpedia

    Recent news

    The link below is to the most recent stories in a Google news search for the terms 'North Carolina supreme court' OR 'North Carolina court election' OR 'North Carolina elections 2016'. These results are automatically generated from Google. Ballotpedia does not curate or endorse these articles.

    See also

    North Carolina Judicial Selection More Courts
    Seal of North Carolina.png
    Judicialselectionlogo.png
    BP logo.png
    Courts in North Carolina
    North Carolina Court of Appeals
    North Carolina Supreme Court
    Elections: 202520242023202220212020201920182017
    Gubernatorial appointments
    Judicial selection in North Carolina
    Federal courts
    State courts
    Local courts

    External links

    Footnotes

    1. General Assembly of North Carolina, "House Bill 222 / S.L. 2015-66," accessed March 7, 2016
    2. Ballot Access News, "North Carolina State Court Invalidates New Law Providing for Retention Elections for State Supreme Court Justices," March 4, 2016
    3. General Assembly of North Carolina, "North Carolina State Constitution," accessed March 7, 2016
    4. The News & Observer, "New uncertainties about NC Supreme Court elections," March 11, 2016
    5. Hastings Tribune, "Court tie means no retention elections for justices, for now," May 6, 2016
    6. 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 Daily Reflector, "Congressional, judicial voting begins Thursday," May 25, 2016
    7. 7.0 7.1 Carolina Public Press, "Handful of voters decide on Supreme Court, Congress," accessed June 8, 2016
    8. News & Record, "Turnout in Guilford surpasses statewide turnout of 7.7 percent," June 7, 2016
    9. Re-elect Justice Edmunds, Supreme Court, "Endorsements," accessed May 31, 2016
    10. The Charlotte Observer, "Talented crop running for Supreme Court," May 29, 2016
    11. NC State AFL-CIO, "Sabra Faires, Alma Adams, and 10 other things to know about June 7th primary," May 27, 2016
    12. Indy Week, "N.C. Supreme Court Associate Justice: We Endorse Michael R. Morgan," June 1, 2016
    13. People's Alliance PAC, "Peoples Alliance PAC Endorses Mike Morgan for North Carolina Supreme Court," accessed June 1, 2016
    14. Sierra Club of Western North Carolina, "Political," accessed June 7, 2016
    15. The News & Observer, "McCrory calls on Republicans to back Justice Bob Edmunds in Tuesday’s primary," June 6, 2016
    16. ThePilot.com, "Sabra Faires Is Best for Supreme Court," June 1, 2016
    17. North Carolina Conservatives Political Action Committee, "Endorsements," accessed September 7, 2016
    18. Grass Roots North Carolina, "A Judge's Conflict of Interest," July 24, 2016
    19. Judge Mike Morgan NC Supreme Court, "Endorsements," accessed September 19, 2016
    20. 20.0 20.1 20.2 Facing South: The Online Magazine of the Institute for Southern Studies, "Business interests spend big on pivotal N.C. Supreme Court primary," June 3, 2016
    21. YouTube, "NC Chamber ad on Bob Edmunds, NC Supreme Court," posted by Nathan Babcock, accessed July 12, 2016
    22. Brennan Center for Justice, "Buy Time 2016 - North Carolina
    23. The News & Observer, "Recount confirms Beasley's win in NC Supreme Court race," November 24, 2014
    24. 24.0 24.1 24.2 American Judicature Society, "Methods of Judicial Selection: North Carolina," archived October 6, 2014
    25. North Carolina Legislature, "Report of the Judicial Selection Study Commission," February 15, 1989
    26. North Carolina Courts, "The North Carolina Judicial System," 2008
    27. North Carolina General Statutes, "General Statutes § 7A-4.20," accessed September 2, 2014
    28. The raw data for this study was provided by Dave Leip of Atlas of U.S. Presidential Elections.