Missed our WV Supreme Court webinar? And an update on the situation
ICYMI: Yesterday, Ballotpedia staff writer Sara Reynolds and I discussed the situation with the West Virginia State Supreme Court.
An update since we recorded the webinar:
On September 11, the West Virginia State Senate held a pretrial hearing.
Senators rejected a motion to adopt a censure resolution against Justices Beth Walker and Margaret Workman. The resolution would have required the justices to accept and acknowledge the problems identified during the proceedings, take responsibility for their role, and commit to continuing the process of establishing and implementing preventative policies. In exchange, the charges would have been dropped.
Del. John Shott (R) said he thought the resolution was fair, necessary, and would be "a good first step to rebuilding the trust" in the judiciary. Sen. President Mitch Carmichael (R) said senators needed to hear evidence before they could vote on the resolution.
The Senate also rejected a motion, 15-19, from Senate Judiciary Chairman Charles Trump (R) to remove Justice Robin Davis from the impeachment trials. Trump argued Davis' resignation meant she no longer qualified to be tried. Sen. Robert Karnes (R) said Davis should be tried to prevent her from serving as a senior status judge, should she be found guilty. Sen. Craig Blair (R) said, "We want to make sure that, if the judge is guilty, they can’t run for office again." He also said he wanted Davis to have an opportunity to dispute the charges.
Acting Chief Justice Paul Farrell set trial dates for Justices Davis, Loughry, Walker, and Workman. They are:
- October 1: Justice Walker
- October 15: Justice Workman
- October 29: Justice Davis
- November 12: Justice Loughry.
All of the justices denied the charges against them. The Senate adjourned until Walker's trial on October 1.
|