Everything you need to know about ranked-choice voting in one spot. Click to learn more!

Gisele Pollack

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
BP-Initials-UPDATED.png
Ballotpedia does not currently cover this office or maintain this page. Please contact us with any updates.
Gisele Pollack
Image of Gisele Pollack
Prior offices
Broward County Court

Education

Bachelor's

University of Miami

Law

University of Miami


Gisele Pollack is a former county judge for the Criminal Division of the Broward County Court in Broward County, Florida.[1] She was elected to the court in 2004.[2] Pollack resigned from the bench rather than face removal in January 2015.[3][4][5] See "In the news" section below.

Education

Pollack received both her undergraduate and J.D. degrees from the University of Miami.[6]

Career

Before she became a judge for the Broward County Court, Pollack served as a public defender with the Broward County Public Defender’s office and worked as an attorney in private practice.[2]

Noteworthy events

Pollack facing formal charges for showing up at work drunk (2014)

See also: Politicians convicted of DUI


The Florida Judicial Qualifications Commission formally charged Pollack for violations of the judicial code of conduct. According to the commission, Pollack violated the terms of an agreement she made with the commission's investigative panel on March 3, 2014. In the agreement, Pollack agreed she would not use alcohol and if she did use alcohol, she would not take the bench.[3]

According to the notice of formal charges, Pollack was drunk when she took the bench on March 19. She was behaving erratically, and her speech was sometimes slurred. She had to be helped off the bench by another judge. Following the incident, Pollack placed herself in an inpatient treatment program for substance abuse.[3]

On May 1, Pollack left the program, without completing it. According to a police report, at approximately 1:30 a.m. on May 2, the vehicle Pollack was driving "struck another vehicle, causing personal injuries." She was arrested and faced charges for driving under the influence. Pollack was placed on leave without pay on May 23, 2013. She was to remain suspended until the commission resolved the case against her.[7]

Pollack's attorney filed a request with the Florida Supreme Court, asking that Pollack be placed on paid leave. He told the court his client suffered from alcoholism, which would be considered a disability under the Americans with Disabilities Act.

If, in fact, Judge Pollack had been suffering from cancer or another disability that required her to be out of office in treatment or therapy, such a restriction would not have been appropriate.[8]
—David Bogenschutz[9]

However, the supreme court rejected the request for a paid suspension.[10]

On September 4, 2014, Pollack pleaded guilty, despite her attorneys' recommendations to plead no contest.

With all due respect to Mr. Schwartzreich and Mr. Catalano, I am going to plead guilty because I am guilty. I am guilty of letting myself down and I am guilty of letting my community down … I am not here to make excuses.[8]

She was sentenced with six months of probation, a $500 fine, 75 hours of community service, and the use of an electronic monitor that would alert a probation officer if she consumed any alcohol. The Judicial Qualifications Commission scheduled a hearing for November 13, 2014. The commission was to decide on a recommendation for the Florida Supreme Court on what action should be taken in regards to Pollack. Her punishment could have been as light as a reprimand, or as serious as removal from office.[11]

Update January 2015: On January 5, 2015, the Florida Judicial Qualifications Commission's hearing panel, by an affirmative vote of at least two-thirds, recommended that Pollack be removed from her office.[12] The hearing panel noted Pollack's committal to recovery, but nevertheless, could not overlook the fact that she had been just as committed when she had executed the stipulation on March 3, 2014, to not use alcohol and assume the bench. The panel further stated that they recognized that alcoholism was a disease which "may explain Judge Pollack’s behavior but it cannot excuse it."[2]

We [the panel] admire her resolve, commend her apparent commitment to recovery, and wish her only success in this endeavor. We owe our allegiance however, to the people of Florida, not any individual judge...Public trust and confidence in the judiciary is, and must remain, our priority.[8]
Florida Judicial Qualifications Commission

Pollack's case was going to be heard by the Florida Supreme Court, who was to make the final determination. However, Pollack resigned prior to removal from office.[4][5][12]

See also

External links

Footnotes