Help us improve in just 2 minutes—share your thoughts in our reader survey.

Marion County Superior Court, Indiana

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Local Courts
Trial-Courts-Ballotpedia.png
Trial courts and judges
Elections by state
Judicial selection by state
View courts by state:

The Marion County Superior Court resides in Indiana. Click on the links below to learn more about the court's...

Jurisdiction

This court holds the following jurisdiction:[1][2]

Sec. 1.5. All standard superior courts have:

(1) original and concurrent jurisdiction in all civil cases and in all criminal cases;

(2) original and concurrent jurisdiction with the circuit courts in all user fee cases;

(3) de novo appellate jurisdiction of appeals from city and town courts; and

(4) in Marion County, de novo appellate jurisdiction of appeals from township small claims courts established under IC 33-34.[3]

Sec. 2. All superior courts have:

(1) original and concurrent jurisdiction in all civil cases and in all criminal cases;

(2) original and concurrent jurisdiction with the circuit courts in all user fee cases;

(3) de novo appellate jurisdiction of appeals from city and town courts; and

(4) in Marion County, de novo appellate jurisdiction of appeals from township small claims courts established under IC 33-34.[3]

Judges


Office Name Party Date assumed office
Marion County Superior Court Marshelle Broadwell January 1, 2021
Marion County Superior Court Linda E. Brown
Marion County Superior Court David Certo Nonpartisan 2007
Marion County Superior Court John Chavis
Marion County Superior Court Jane Spencer Craney Nonpartisan
Marion County Superior Court Stephen Creason
Marion County Superior Court Angela Davis Nonpartisan
Marion County Superior Court PJ Dietrick Nonpartisan
Marion County Superior Court Kurt Eisgruber Nonpartisan
Marion County Superior Court Geoffrey Gaither January 1, 2021
Marion County Superior Court Ryan K. Gardner January 1, 2021
Marion County Superior Court Charnette D. Garner January 1, 2019
Marion County Superior Court Danielle Gaughan Nonpartisan 2022
Marion County Superior Court Alicia Gooden
Marion County Superior Court Clayton Graham
Marion County Superior Court Jennifer P. Harrison January 1, 2019
Marion County Superior Court Amy Jones
Marion County Superior Court James A. Joven
Marion County Superior Court Melanie Kendrick Nonpartisan
Marion County Superior Court Marie Kern Nonpartisan February 21, 2024
Marion County Superior Court Christina R. Klineman Nonpartisan
Marion County Superior Court Helen Marchal
Marion County Superior Court Jeffrey Marchal Nonpartisan 2022
Marion County Superior Court Charles F. Miller
Marion County Superior Court Gary L. Miller Nonpartisan 2013
Marion County Superior Court William J. Nelson
Marion County Superior Court Timothy W. Oakes Nonpartisan January 1, 2009
Marion County Superior Court Cynthia L. Oetjen Nonpartisan February 24, 2021
Marion County Superior Court James B. Osborn Nonpartisan January 1, 2009
Marion County Superior Court Clark Rogers
Marion County Superior Court Marc Rothenberg Nonpartisan January 1, 2009
Marion County Superior Court Jose D. Salinas
Marion County Superior Court Philip Sheward Nonpartisan


Elections

Indiana is one of 43 states that hold elections for judicial positions. To learn more about judicial selection in Indiana, click here.

Selection method

See also: Judicial selection in the states
See also: Partisan election of judges

The 196 judges of the Indiana Superior Courts are generally chosen in an identical manner. Judges are elected in partisan elections to six-year terms, after which they must run for re-election if they wish to serve additional terms.[4]

Some exceptions apply:

  • Superior court judges from Allen County are chosen in nonpartisan elections.
  • Superior court judges from the counties of Lake, Marion, and St. Joseph are appointed by the governor from lists of potential candidates submitted by the local nominating commissions (this excludes judges of Lake County's county division superior court, who must be elected). Judges then stand for retention in the first general election taking place two or more years after their appointment.[4]

Qualifications
Though some counties have imposed additional qualifications, a judge serving on these courts must at least be:

  • a circuit resident and
  • admitted to practice law in the state.[4]

Judicial elections in Indiana

See also: Indiana judicial elections

Indiana is one of eight states that use partisan elections to initially select judges and then use retention elections to determine whether judges should remain on the bench. To read more about how states use judicial elections to select judges across the country, click here.

Primary election

In the primary, most candidates for the trial courts compete in partisan elections.

Exceptions are:

  • Circuit court candidates in Vanderburgh County run in nonpartisan elections.
  • Superior court candidates in Allen and Vanderburgh counties compete in nonpartisan elections.
  • Judges in Lake and St. Joseph counties are appointed by the Governor and stand for retention two years into service and at the end of subsequent terms.[5]
  • When a superior court vacancy occurs in Marion County, candidates are reviewed by a 14-member judicial selection committee, which sends the names of three nominees to the governor. The governor must appoint one of the nominees as judge within 60 days. At the end of a judge's term on the court, the question of the judge's retention may be placed on the general election ballot. Before a judge can stand for retention, the judge must appear before the committee to allow the committee to issue a recommendation to voters regarding the judge's suitability to continue to hold office.[6]

General election

Superior court judges in Lake and St. Joseph Counties stand for retention. All other trial court judges compete in contested races.[5][7]

If a vacancy occurs mid-term on the Indiana Supreme Court or Indiana Court of Appeals, the governor makes an appointment from names supplied by the judicial nominating commission. Vacancies on the circuit and superior courts are filled by direct governor appointment. Appointed judges must then run in the next general election, or the next general election after two years in office for supreme and appellate appointees.[7]

Unopposed candidates

If there is no contest for a judicial seat in either the primary or general election, the candidates for that seat are not placed on the primary ballot. Candidates who are unopposed in the primary, however, must still appear on the primary ballot if there is any opposition for the seat by any other party.[8]


See also



External links

Footnotes