Your feedback ensures we stay focused on the facts that matter to you most—take our survey.

Endorsements in Colorado school board elections, 2023

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
SchoolBoardsPortalMastheadImage.png
School Board Endorsements
2023
School Board badge.png

Overview:
Regular electionsRecalls

State-specific analyses:
ColoradoKansasMinnesotaOhioOklahomaPennsylvaniaSouth DakotaVirginiaWashingtonWisconsin

School board elections by state:

Previous coverage:
Conflicts in school board elections


Colorado held elections for 325 of the state's 978 school board seats on November 7. These elections took place across 103 of the state's 178 school districts. The remaining 75 districts canceled their elections due to a lack of candidates, accounting for 198 seats. Overall, 523 seats were up for election in 2023.

While Colorado's school board elections are officially nonpartisan, Ballotpedia researched publicly available voter files and candidate filing information to identify the partisan affiliation of candidates running in these elections.

Overall, of the 523 seats up for election:

  • Registered Democrats won 20%
  • Registered Republicans won 50%
  • Registered independents or minor party candidates won 25%
  • Candidates whose affiliation could not be identified won 6%[1]

Those totals include uncontested and contested intra-party elections, which accounted for 52% and 9% of all seats up for election, respectively.

The remaining 39% of elections were between candidates with different partisan affiliations, described as contested inter-party elections. In these elections, registered Democrats and Republicans had win-rates of 58% and 55%, respectively.

This page includes other analyses of Colorado's school board elections, including open seats and incumbent defeat rates.

Incumbents ran for re-election to 51% of the seats, leaving 49% of seats open, above average compared to Ballotpedia's historical coverage.

Eighty-six percent of incumbents who ran for re-election won, but 55% ran unopposed. Of the 121 incumbents who faced opposition, 30% lost, above average compared to Ballotpedia's historical coverage.

This report also includes a catalog of every endorsement identified, along with breakdowns among the groups that issued the most endorsements.

Smart Choice Colorado issued the most endorsements overall, and the most among conservative endorsers. The group's endorsees had a 37% win rate in contested elections.

The Colorado Education Association and its local affiliates issued the most endorsements among liberal endorsers and had a 69% win rate in contested elections.

Use the links below to navigate to:

Election results

Colorado held 200 elections for 325 school board seats in 2023. An additional 198 seats were up for election in districts that ultimately canceled those elections due to a lack of candidates, leaving 523 seats up for election.[2]

  • Registered Democrats won 102 seats (20%)
  • Registered Republicans won 260 seats (50%)
  • Registered independents or minor party candidates won 129 seats (25%)
  • Candidates whose affiliation could not be identified won 32 seats (6%)

The table below shows election results based on the party registration of the winning candidate. There were three types of elections:

  • Uncontested, where there was no election. Ballotpedia was unable to provide a partisan analysis of uncontested races.
  • Contested intra-party, where there was a contested election between members of the same political party; and,
  • Contested inter-party, where there was a contested election between members of different political parties.

Figures show how many seats were won by candidates with the given party registration.

Colorado school board election winners, 2023
Party Uncontested Contested intra-party Contested inter-party Total
# % # % # % # %
Democrats 36 6.9% 9 1.7% 57 10.9% 102 19.5%
Republicans 139 26.6% 30 5.7% 91 17.4% 260 49.7%
Other 70 13.4% 6 1.1% 53 10.1% 129 24.7%
Unknown[3] 29 5.5% 0 0.0% 3 0.6% 32 6.1%
Total 274 52.4% 45 8.6% 204 39.0% 523


There were 142 uncontested elections for 274 seats, representing 52% of all seats up for election.

This includes data from 75 districts that canceled their elections due to a lack of candidates. There were 198 seats up for election in those districts, accounting for 72% of all uncontested seats and 37% of all seats up for election in 2023.


There were 31 contested intra-party elections for 45 seats, representing 9% of all seats up for election. Intra-party elections are contested elections, meaning at least one candidate must lose, but every candidate on the ballot has the same party affiliation.

There were eight intra-ideological elections between Democrats, 17 between Republicans, and six between independent or minor party candidates.


There were 105 contested inter-party elections for 204 seats, representing 39% of all seats up for election. Inter-party elections are contested elections featuring candidates with different party affiliations.

Republicans won a plurality of seats in contested inter-party elections (45%), followed by Democrats (28%), and independent or minor party candidates (26%).


Click on the tab below to view full Colorado election results
Show more


The spreadsheet below shows results from Colorado's November 7 general elections. The leftmost columns show district names, the offices up for election within those districts, and the number of seats up for election within those offices.

Winning and defeated candidates are shown under their respective columns and are highlighted based on their ideological lean as determined by the endorsements they received.

  • Blue highlights indicate a liberal ideological lean
  • Red highlights indicate a conservative ideological lean
  • Purple highlights indicate a mixed ideological lean
  • Dark gray highlights indicate the candidate received only neutral or unclear endorsements
  • Light gray highlights indicate Ballotpedia identified no endorsements for the candidate

Winning candidates marked with (WI) are write-in candidates who won elections for which no candidates appeared on the ballot. The St. Vrain School District and any other district labeled with (NC) are districts that canceled their November elections.

Incumbents are marked with a dark gray square to the right of their name.

Party performance

This section displays win and loss rates for candidates by party affiliation, showing how they performed in contested inter-party elections.

In these contested inter-party elections:

  • 99 Democrats ran, 57 of whom (58%) won;
  • 165 Republicans ran, 91 of whom (55%) won;
  • 116 independent or minor party candidates ran, 53 of whom (46%) won; and,
  • Four candidates whose affiliations could not be identified ran, three of whom (75%) won.
Party performance in contested inter-party Colorado school board elections, 2023
Ideology Candidates Won Lost
# % # %
Democratic 99 57 57.6% 42 42.4%
Republican 165 91 55.2% 74 44.8%
Other 116 53 45.7% 63 54.3%
Unknown 4 3 75.0% 1 25.0%

Incumbency

Open seats

Of the 523 seats up for election, 266 incumbents ran for re-election (51%), leaving 257 seats open (49%). This open seat rate was above average compared to Ballotpedia's regular coverage scope over the preceding five years.

Between 2018 and 2022, on average, Ballotpedia recorded a 29% open seat rate within its regular coverage scope.

Overall, 178 districts held elections on November 7. Of that total, 32 districts (18%) had no open seats, 103 (58%) had some open seats, and, in 43 (24%), all seats were open.

Incumbents defeated

Of the 266 incumbents who ran for re-election, 230 won (86%), and 36 lost (14%). This overall loss rate was average compared to Ballotpedia's regular coverage scope over the preceding five years.

Between 2018 and 2022, on average, Ballotpedia recorded a 16% overall loss rate within its regular coverage scope.

The percentage of incumbents defeated increases to 30% when looking only at the 121 incumbents who ran in contested elections, those where an incumbent could have lost. This contested loss rate was above average compared to Ballotpedia's regular coverage scope over the preceding five years.

Between 2018 and 2022, on average, Ballotpedia recorded a 26% contested loss rate within its regular coverage scope.

Overall, 178 districts held elections on November 7. Of that total, no incumbents lost in 106 districts (60%), some incumbents lost in 19 districts (11%), and all incumbents lost in 10 districts (6%). There were 43 districts (24%) where no incumbents ran for re-election.

Endorsements

Top endorsers

The table below shows the top 11 endorsers in Colorado in terms of the total number of endorsements made. It includes a hoverable column with information about each endorser, the number of candidates they endorsed, and the number of endorsees who won, both in terms of all endorsees and among only those in contested elections.[4][5]

Top Colorado school board endorsers, 2023
Endorser Info All Contested
Endorsees Won % Lost % Endorsees Won % Lost %
Smart Choice Colorado About 104 46 44.2% 58 55.8% 92 34 37.0% 58 63.0%
Colorado Conservative Patriot Alliance About 98 38 38.8% 60 61.2% 89 29 32.6% 60 67.4%
Colorado Education Association About 78 56 71.8% 22 28.2% 71 49 69.0% 22 31.0%
Democratic Party of Colorado About 43 33 76.7% 10 23.3% 42 32 76.2% 10 23.8%
Everytown for Gun Safety About 36 21 58.3% 15 41.7% 35 20 57.1% 15 42.9%
Republican Party of Colorado About 24 4 16.7% 20 83.3% 23 3 13.0% 20 87.0%
Colorado AFL-CIO About 11 5 45.5% 6 54.5% 11 5 45.5% 6 54.5%
Democratic State Board of Ed. members About 11 8 72.7% 3 27.3% 11 8 72.7% 3 27.3%
Americans for Prosperity Reg. Dir. Jeff Crank About 10 8 80.0% 2 20.0% 10 8 80.0% 2 20.0%
Voces Unidas Action Fund About 10 10 100.0% 0 0.0% 6 6 100.0% 0 0.0%

Top endorsees

The table below shows the 10 candidates who received the most endorsements. It includes candidates, the offices they ran for, the total number of endorsements they received based on the partisan lean of the endorser, and their election results. Incumbents are marked with (i).

Top Colorado school board endorsees, 2023
Candidate District Endorsers Result
Liberal Conservative Other
Lori Goldstein Adams 12 Five Star Schools 38 0 0 Won
Neil Fishman Boulder Valley School District 33 0 0 Lost
Derrick Wilburn Academy School District 20 0 27 0 Won
Alex Medler Boulder Valley School District 21 0 2 Won
Jessica Zamora Poudre School District R-1 19 0 0 Won
Scott Baldermann Denver Public Schools 16 0 1 Lost
Kevin Havelda Poudre School District R-1 17 0 0 Won
Jason Unger Boulder Valley School District 14 0 3 Won
Lalenia Quinlan Aweida Boulder Valley School District 13 0 2 Won
Amy Shandy Academy School District 20 0 14 0 Won

Full endorsements list

The table below lists all endorsements identified by Ballotpedia among Colorado school board candidates in 2023. The list is sorted alphabetically by district name. Click the headers to adjust sorting or use the search bar to look for specific districts, candidates, or endorsers. If a source link is not functioning properly, all links were archived with the Internet Archive if possible.

Candidate information

Candidate ages

In Colorado, birth year information is made publicly available in the state's voter file. Using this data, Ballotpedia found that the average school board candidate was 48.6 years old. This increased to 50.3 years old for Democrats and decreased to 48.4 and 47.7 years old for Republicans and all other candidates, respectively.

The table below shows the distribution of the 523 seats up for election based on the age range of the candidates who won those seats.

Colorado school board election winners by age range, 2023
Age range Uncontested Contested Total
# % # % # %
18-24 1 0.4% 0 0.0% 1 0.2%
25-34 20 7.3% 13 5.2% 33 6.3%
35-44 92 33.6% 87 34.9% 179 34.2%
45-54 78 28.5% 72 28.9% 150 28.7%
55-64 30 10.9% 38 15.3% 68 13.0%
65-74 19 6.9% 30 12.0% 49 9.4%
75+ 5 1.8% 5 2.0% 10 1.9%
Unknown[6] 29 10.6% 4 1.6% 33 6.3%
Total 274 249 523


The graphic below shows how many candidates won and lost from each age range.

Candidates aged 45 to 54 had the highest win rate, at 72% overall and 56% in contested elections.

Candidates aged 18 to 24 had the lowest win rate, but only three were on the ballot in 2023.

The next lowest was candidates aged 65 to 75, with a 64% win rate overall.

That changes when focusing only on contested elections, at which point those aged 25 to 34 had the next lowest win rate at 45%.

Oldest and youngest candidates

The table below lists the 10 youngest and oldest candidates who ran in Colorado's school board elections in 2023. It also includes the district where they ran, whether the election was contested or uncontested, and their election results. Incumbents are marked with (i).

Ten youngest and oldest Colorado school board candidates, 2023
Candidate Age District Status Result
Youngest candidates
Maria Garcia 22 Sheridan School District 2 Cont. Lost
Angel Bujanda Gutierrez 23 Lake County School District R-1 Uncont. Won
Shay Dabney 24 Colorado Springs School District 11 Cont. Lost
Caleb Larson 25 Poudre School District R-1 Cont. Lost
Brett Wilson (i) 26 Pritchett School District RE-3 Uncont. Won
Tiffany Tasker 27 Adams-Arapahoe School District 28J Cont. Won
Nathan Strickland 27 Burlington School District RE-6J Cont. Lost
Miriam Lozano (i) 27 Lake County School District R-1 Uncont. Won
Sadie Wardell 27 Huerfano School District RE-1 Uncont. Won
Kaylin Harju 28 Garfield School District RE-2 Cont. Lost
Brett Krager 28 Prairie School District RE-11 Cont. Lost
Morgan Dayne Rummel 28 Norwood School District R-2J Cont. Won
Oldest candidates
Vance Alfrey (i) 81 Vilas School District RE-5 Uncont. Won
Judy Book 80 Big Sandy School District 100J Cont. Won
Tom Olmstead 79 Lewis-Palmer School District 38 Cont. Lost
Roger L. Wright 79 Pueblo City School District 60 Cont. Lost
George Richardson 78 Buena Vista School District R-31 Uncont. Won
Dennis Maes (i) 78 Pueblo City School District 60 Cont. Won
James Berthold (i) 77 St. Vrain Valley School District RE 1J Uncont. Won
Greg Kruthaupt 77 Gunnison Watershed School District RE-1J Cont. Lost
James Charles Watkins 76 Crowley County School District RE-1-J Cont. Won
Leo Mekelburg 76 Frenchman School District RE-3 Cont. Lost
Bill Thiebaut 76 Pueblo City School District 60 Cont. Won
Stu Boyd (i) 76 Thompson School District R-2J Cont. Won
David Schmittel 76 Mountain Valley School District RE-1 Uncont. Won
Suzanne Hamill (i) 76 South Routt School District RE-3 Uncont. Won

District information

Student-to-teacher ratio

The map below displays the student-to-teacher ratio in all Colorado school districts. Hover for additional district characteristics.

Methodology

Terms and definitions

Descriptive endorsements

This research focuses on descriptive endorsements, those that help describe the stances or policy positions of a candidate. This is based on the assumption that endorsers tend to endorse candidates holding one or multiple positions that align with those of the endorser. If an endorser's positions are not readily apparent, their endorsements are not considered descriptive endorsements.

Examples of endorsers whose endorsements might be considered descriptive include political parties, issue-based organizations with clear policy stances, unions, current or former elected officials, and current or former party officers.

Apart from this section, any mention of endorsements refers to descriptive endorsements.

Endorser

An endorser is an individual or organization that has made a descriptive endorsement. Examples of which include, but are not limited to:

Individuals:

  • Elected or former partisan officials
  • Current or former party officers
  • Individuals associated with a clear policy stance

Organizations:

  • Unions
  • Issue-based organizations with clear policy stances
  • Political parties

Process

Identifying endorsements

Ballotpedia gathers endorsements using four primary methods:

  • Submissions: Readers can submit endorsement information to Ballotpedia directly using this link. Ballotpedia staff reviews all submitted information daily to determine whether it warrants inclusion. Reader-submitted endorsements must include a link to a source verifying the endorsement to be included.
  • Candidate Connection Surveys: Candidates who complete Ballotpedia's Candidate Connection Survey are asked to share any endorsements they have received. Any submitted endorsements will appear in the candidate's survey responses. Ballotpedia staff also reviews every survey with endorsement information to determine whether those submissions include descriptive endorsements to add to our overall tracking process. Candidates are invited to submit links to sources for their endorsements, but this is not required.[7]
  • Outreach: Ballotpedia staff contacts endorsers directly to request endorsement lists. At the start of the election cycle, every endorser will receive an email requesting information. Ballotpedia staff also contacts endorsers to clarify information and, if we see they have endorsed one candidate, to determine whether they have also endorsed others.
  • Direct research: Ballotpedia staff conducts direct research, regularly checking all identified endorsers and relevant news media in each state. This research might also include looking at specific districts or candidates where endorsement activity appears likely.

Recording endorsements

Once an endorsement has been identified, it is recorded along with the date it was made (if known), a link to the source of the endorsement, and the date Ballotpedia staff learned of the endorsement. If possible, Ballotpedia archives every web source used to identify an endorsement.

For every recorded endorsement, Ballotpedia staff prepare a brief summary of the endorser. For individuals, this might include the party they are affiliated with, their statements regarding a particular policy, or their electoral history. For organizations, this might include the standards by which they issue endorsements, their mission statement, or any other statements regarding a particular policy. When available, Ballotpedia uses direct quotes from endorsers in these summaries, which appear beside each endorsement to provide added context to readers.

Labeling

After identifying an endorsement, Ballotpedia applies a partisan ideology label based on the policies the endorser supports or affiliation with other partisan organizations. Those labels are:

  • Liberal: the endorser is either affiliated with the Democratic Party, supports traditionally liberal education policies, or opposes traditionally conservative education policies without also opposing traditionally liberal policies.
  • Conservative: the endorser is either affiliated with the Republican Party, supports traditionally conservative education policies, or opposes traditionally liberal education policies without also opposing traditionally conservative policies.
  • Neutral: the endorser is not affiliated with either major party and does not take specific policy stances, supportive or otherwise, examples of which include local newspapers.
  • Unclear: the endorser would be of interest to voters, but Ballotpedia could not identify a partisan ideology, examples of which include former school board members.

As part of this analysis, Ballotpedia then uses the labels applied to endorsers to determine the partisan ideology of the endorsed candidate. Those resulting candidate ideology labels are:

  • Liberal: the candidate received an endorsement from a liberal endorser and none from conservative endorsers.
  • Conservative: the candidate received an endorsement from a conservative endorser and none from liberal endorsers.
  • Mixed: the candidate received endorsements from liberal and conservative endorsers.
  • Other: the candidate received endorsements from either neutral or unclear endorsers and none from liberal or conservative endorsers.

While candidates can receive a mixture of endorsements, primacy is given to liberal and conservative endorsements. For example, if a candidate received endorsements from liberal and neutral endorsers, their ideology label would be liberal.

Timing

Ballotpedia tracks and gathers endorsement information throughout the election cycle. If a district holds primary elections, endorsements are only added on-site after the primary date.

Voter registration

While most school board elections are officially nonpartisan, meaning candidates appear on the ballot without party labels, the state makes voter registration information publicly available. Ballotpedia used this information to identify each candidate's party registration in Colorado, Kansas, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, and South Dakota. Note: a candidate's party registration status does not necessarily indicate the candidate's personal ideologies. Many voters register to vote with one party and later find themselves more aligned with another party but do not update their registration as such. Understanding that their registration information is effectively public, voters may also choose a certain registration or affiliate with no party, with that in mind.

Ballotpedia first compared candidate names and school districts to the publicly available voter file to tie candidates with their party registration. The associated voter information was logged if the candidate’s name only appeared once in the school district. If the candidate’s name appeared multiple times in a single school district, Ballotpedia looked at each voter file entry to match the registration address with other identifiable information associated with the candidate. This method accounted for all duplicate entries.

If a candidate was registered under a different name than the one they filed to run with (i.e. registered as Robert Smith but running as Bob Smith), Ballotpedia used a variety of methods to pinpoint the candidate’s voter file information including:

  • Looking for every person with the same last name as the candidate in the school district;
  • Identifying known associates (i.e. children, spouses), and using public records to determine if any households had changed addresses;
  • Utilizing publicly available social media information; or,
  • A mixture of these three approaches.

Labeling

After identifying an endorsement, Ballotpedia applies a partisan ideology label based on the policies the endorser supports or affiliation with other partisan organizations. Those labels are:

  • Liberal: the endorser is either affiliated with the Democratic Party or supports traditionally liberal education policies.
  • Conservative: the endorser is either affiliated with the Republican Party or supports traditionally conservative education policies.
  • Neutral: the endorser is not affiliated with either major party and does not take specific policy stances, examples of which include local newspapers.
  • Unclear: the endorser would be of interest to voters, but Ballotpedia could not identify a partisan ideology, examples of which include former school board members.

As part of this analysis, Ballotpedia then uses the labels applied to endorsers to determine the partisan ideology of the endorsed candidate. Those resulting candidate ideology labels are:

  • Liberal: the candidate received an endorsement from a liberal endorser and none from conservative endorsers.
  • Conservative: the candidate received an endorsement from a conservative endorser and none from liberal endorsers.
  • Mixed: the candidate received endorsements from liberal and conservative endorsers.
  • Other: the candidate received endorsements from either neutral or unclear endorsers and none from liberal or conservative endorsers.

While candidates can receive a mixture of endorsements, primacy is given to liberal and conservative endorsements. For example, if a candidate received endorsements from liberal and neutral endorsers, their ideology label would be liberal.

Voter registration

While Colorado's school board elections are officially nonpartisan, meaning candidates appear on the ballot without party labels, the state makes voter registration information publicly available. Ballotpedia used this information to identify each candidate's party registration. Note: a candidate's party registration status does not necessarily indicate the candidate's personal ideologies. Many voters register to vote with one party and, later on, find themselves more aligned with another party but do not update their registration as such. Understanding that their registration information is effectively public, voters may also choose a certain registration, or affiliate with no party, with that in mind.

To tie candidates with their party registration, Ballotpedia first compared candidate names and school districts to the publicly available voter file. If the candidate’s name only appeared once in the school district, the associated voter information was logged. If the candidate’s name appeared multiple times in a single school district, Ballotpedia looked at each voter file entry to match the registration address with other identifiable information associated with the candidate. This method accounted for all duplicate entries.

If a candidate was registered under a different name than the one they filed to run with (i.e. registered as Robert Smith but running as Bob Smith), Ballotpedia used a variety of methods to pinpoint the candidate’s voter file information including:

  • Looking for every person with the same last name as the candidate in the school district;
  • Identifying known associates (i.e. children, spouses), and using public records to determine if any households had changed addresses;
  • Utilizing publicly available social media information; or,
  • A mixture of these three approaches.

Elections by county

Navigate to Colorado 2023 local elections overviews:
Adams | Alamosa | Arapahoe | Archuleta | Baca | Bent | Boulder | Broomfield | Chaffee | Cheyenne | Clear Creek | Conejos | Costilla | Crowley | Custer | Delta | Denver | Dolores | Douglas | Eagle | Elbert | El Paso | Fremont | Garfield | Gilpin | Grand | Gunnison | Hinsdale | Huerfano | Jackson | Jefferson | Kiowa | Kit Carson | Lake | La Plata | Larimer | Las Animas | Lincoln | Logan | Mesa | Mineral | Moffat | Montezuma | Montrose | Morgan | Otero | Ouray | Park | Phillips | Pitkin | Prowers | Pueblo | Rio Blanco | Rio Grande | Routt | Saguache | San Juan | San Miguel | Sedgwick | Summit | Teller | Washington | Weld | Yuma

See also

Footnotes

  1. This includes five candidates who filed to run for office and 28 seats where no candidates filed to run, creating vacancies to be filled by appointment after the election.
  2. The number of elections and seats differs due to the presence of multi-member districts.

    136 elections were for single seats.
    58 elections were for two seats.
    70 elections were for three seats.
    Nine elections were for four seats.
    Five elections were for five seats
  3. Ballotpedia could not identified the partisan affiliation of these winners. This includes five candidates who appeared on the ballot and 23 seats where no candidates filed to run, creating vacancies to be filled by appointment after the election.
  4. Contested elections refer to any with more candidates running than seats available, meaning at least one candidate must lose.
  5. These totals only include those candidates who received an endorsement and appeared on the general election ballot.
  6. Ballotpedia could not determine these candidates' ages, or they represent uncontested seats in canceled elections that became vacant.
  7. Candidates regularly list endorsements on their campaign websites with no attribution, meant to be taken as true at face value. The same applies to endorsements submitted through surveys. Ballotpedia does not fact-check candidate-submitted information. However, if a candidate submits false information and Ballotpedia learns of this at a later time, their survey responses will be updated to reflect that information.