Georgia Charter Schools, Amendment 1 (2012)
|Charter Schools Amendment|
|Referred by:||Georgia Legislature|
- 1 Election results
- 2 Text of measure
- 3 Background
- 4 Support
- 5 Opposition
- 6 Media editorial positions
- 7 Polls
- 8 Path to the ballot
- 9 See also
- 10 External links
- 11 References
The measure developed following a May 2011 ruling by the Georgia Supreme Court. The court ruled that the state's involvement in the establishment of public charter schools - the Georgia Charter School Commission - was unconstitutional. Specifically, the court ruled that the commission was illegal because it approved and funded charter schools despite objection by local school boards. The ruling does not apply to charter schools that were not opposed by local boards. In total, the ruling is reported to have affected 16 schools.
The Georgia Charter School Commission was created in 2008 in reaction to local school boards rejecting charter petitions. According officials, petitions were rejected because "they didn't like the competition."
- See also: 2012 ballot measure election results
|Georgia Amendment 1|
- These results are from the Georgia Secretary of State and have been certified as final.
Text of measure
The official ballot text read as follows:
Provides for improving student achievement and pa rental involvement through more public charter school options.
House Resolution No. 1162 Ga. L. 2012, p. 1364
Shall the Constitution of Georgia be amended to allow state or local approval of public charter schools upon the request of local communities?( ) NO
( ) YES
This proposal authorizes the General Assembly to provide by law for the creation of public state charter schools, which would operate under the terms of charters between the State Board of Education and charter petitioners, while preserving the authority of local boards of education to establish local charter schools. Specifically, the proposal clarifies the authority of the General Assembly to provide for state-wide policies for public education prior to the college or post-secondary level, restates the authority of the General Assembly to establish special schools, prohibits the incurrence of bonded indebtedness or the levy of school taxes for the support of special schools without approval of the local board of education and the voters in the affected school system, provides that special schools may include public state charter schools, preserves the authority of local boards of education to establish local charter schools, authorizes the expenditure of state funds for special schools, and prohibits the deduction of certain state funds from local school districts as a direct result or consequence of the enrollment of students in state charter schools.
The General Assembly has enacted a law to exercise the authority granted by the proposed constitutional amendment to provide for public state charter schools. This law will become effective only if the constitutional amendment is ratified by the voters. This law is published at Georgia Laws 2012, p, 1298, Sec. 1, and was enacted by 2012 HB 797, Act No. 766.
A copy of this entire proposed constitutional amendment is on file in the office of the judge of the probate court and is available for public inspection.
A bill enabling funding for state charter schools was signed into law on May 3, 2012, by Governor Nathan Deal. The bill, HB 797, will only have effect if the Georgia Charter Schools Amendment gains public approval in November.
- Kyle Wingfield, a columnist for The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, wrote in support of the measure saying that the "key to improving the system, rather than merely pouring more money into it, is restoring the state’s ability to approve charter schools." He further argues that charter school allow for more innovation and accountability while increasing parents' options for education.
- Sen. Crane spoke in support of the measure saying the school boards should not have full control of public education because the state provides about 50 - 80% of the school system's funding. Speaking at a town hall meeting he asked, "Should all the state dollars go to fund a system of education or should it go to the students?"
- Sen. Buddy Carter wrote an opinion piece for the Savannah Morning News that posed counterpoints for a number of arguments against the amendment. Specifically, Sen. Carter argues that the creation of state charter schools will not divert funds from public schools. He also states that the schools are required to be run by local non-profit boards and thus, the amendment would increase local control of education rather than the state's. Sen. Carter also mentions that the amendment is needed due to a Georgia Supreme Court ruling made in 2011 that declared the Georgia Charter Schools Commission unconstitutional because it violated the "special schools" provision of the Georgia constitution.
The opposition campaign to the measure is Vote Smart Georgia.
Following is a list of organizations who stood against Amendment 1:
- GAEL - Georgia Association of Educational Leaders
- Georgia Association of Educators
- Georgia Association of School Psychologist
- GMEA - Georgia Music Educators Assocation
- GPTA - Georgia Parent Teacher Association
- GREA - Georgia Retired Educators Association
- GSBA - Georgia School Boards Association
- GSSA - Georgia School Superintendents Association
- League of Women Voters of GA
- Legislative Black Caucus of GA
- NAACP Georgia State Conference
- PAGE - Professional Association of Georgia Educators
- SEF - Southern Education Foundation
- GFT - Georgia Federation of Teachers
- Georgia State Schools Superintendent Dr. John Barge, a Republican, announced his opposition to the measure, saying, "I cannot support the creation of a new and costly state bureaucracy that takes away local control of schools and unnecessarily duplicates the good work already being done by local districts, the Georgia Department of Education, and the state Board of Education. What's more, this constitutional amendment would direct taxpayer dollars into the pockets of out-of-state, for-profit charter school companies whose schools perform no better than traditional public schools and locally approved charter schools (and worse, in some cases)."
- Gary Hobbs, superintendent for Walton County Public Schools, spoke out against the legislatively-proposed amendment saying, "It’s disappointing to me the legislative folks would try to go around a Supreme Court decision." He went further to criticize the state's push for taxpayer funded charter schools saying, "We don’t have funds to support the public schools we have now, much less start another system funded by taxpayer money."
- Tom Crawford, in an August 21 op-ed piece for the Blackshear Times, highlighted counterpoints to several arguments made by supporters of the charter school amendment. Some of Crawford's key points included: there is enough existing choice for parents because there are already 315 charter schools compared to the just over 500 public schools, studies have shown that charter schools perform no better than public schools on average, charter schools divert money from already strapped public schools that are being forced to shorten their academic calendars.
- Some opponents argued that the amendment would harm public education in the state by directing even more state money from public schools to out-of-state for-profit systems. Russell J. Edwards, an Athens attorney and community activist, argues that such a practice is especially harmful because the housing crisis has caused the primary funding for public education, local property tax receipts, to decrease significantly.
- Sue Ella Deadwyler, creator of the website GeorgiaInsight.org, vocalized her opposition to the amendment, saying that the legislature's creation of charter schools in unconstitutional. During a speech made at the Harvest Christian Community Center, Deadwyler cited her chief complaint about the measure, saying, "Charter schools remove local control by local school boards. Nowhere in the constitution does it say anyone can come in and override the local boards of education."
Tactics and strategies
On Tuesday, September 25, 2012, a coalition of groups protested outside the Georgia Capitol in Atlanta. Senator Emanuel Jones was among the protesters and said, "We do not support this governor's takeover of usurping the power of these locally-elected school boards to make that decision."
Media editorial positions
- Augusta Chronicle said, "We urge you to vote for freedom by voting 'yes' on the amendment, listed as Amendment 1 on your ballot."
- See also: Polls, 2012 ballot measures
- A March 29-30, 2012, poll by McLaughlin & Associates estimated that 58% would vote for the amendment, while 23% would vote against it, and 19% were undecided. A total of 600 likely voters were polled. The margin of error was +/-4%.
- A September 4, 2012, poll by Sand Mountain Communications indicated that 50% would vote for the amendment, while 25% would vote against it, and 25% were undecided. A total of 1,331 likely voters were polled. The margin of error was +/-3%.
|Date of Poll||Pollster||In favor||Opposed||Undecided||Number polled|
|March 29-30, 2012||McLaughlin & Associates||58%||23%||19%||600|
|September 4, 2012||Sand Mountain Communications||50%||25%||25%||1,331|
Path to the ballot
- See also: How the Georgia Constitution is amended
The first vote by the House in early February fell 10 votes shy of the two-thirds majority needed. However, another vote was held on Wednesday, February 22, in which the measure, HR 1162, passed the House with a vote of 123-48.
- The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "The brewing of a bruising fight over charter schools," June 25, 2011
- Associated Press, "General Assembly passes charter school amendment," March 19, 2012
- Associated Press, "Ga. charter schools will learn if they can remain open," June 27, 2011
- Associated Press, "Ga. board committee approves applications of charter schools affected by court ruling," June 27, 2011
- Georgia Secretary of State, "Amendment 1," accessed September 27, 2012
- Georgia Secretary of State, "Proposed Constitutional Amendments, General Election, November 6, 2012," retreived October 10, 2012
- Associated Press, "Gov. Deal Approves Funding System for State-Formed Charter Schools," May 3, 2012
- Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Pass charter schools amendment, get back to fixing education in Georgia," January 26, 2012
- Times-Herald, "Crane speaks on charter schools, DOT, TSPLOST at town hall," May 6, 2012
- Savannah Morning News, "Charter schools a positive for Georgia," September 20, 2012
- Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Barge comes out against charter schools amendment," August 14, 2012
- Walton Tribune, "Charter school amendment draws local fire," January 29, 2012
- Blackshear Times, "CRAWFORD / Here are some facts about Georgia’s charter schools amendment," August 21, 2012
- Athens Banner-Herald, "Edwards: Amendment would hurt public schools," September 18, 2012
- TheCitizen.com, "Charter schools amendment on ballot draws heat," accessed October 10, 2012
- FOX 5 "Charter amendment debated at Ga. Capitol," September 26, 2012
- Families for Better Public Schools campaign website
- Rome News Tribune, "Poll: Charter-school amendment starts with some support, many undecided," June 19, 2012
- Rome News Tribune, "Half of polled voters favor charter-school amendment," September 11, 2012
- Associated Press, "Ga. lawmakers eye vote on creating charter schools," February 22, 2012
- Ledger-Enquirer, "Georgia House passes charter school measure," accessed February 23, 2012
- Associated Press, "Ga. Senate committee passes charter amendment," February 24, 2012