Everything you need to know about ranked-choice voting in one spot. Click to learn more!

Procedural rights: States that place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication (2020)

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
New Administrative State Banner.png
This survey is part of a series of 50-state surveys examining the five pillars key to understanding the administrative state
Administrative State
Administrative State Icon Gold.png
Five Pillars of the Administrative State
Agency control
Executive control
Judicial control
Legislative control
Public Control

Click here for more coverage of the administrative state on Ballotpedia.
Click here to access Ballotpedia's administrative state legislation tracker.


Disclaimer: The research presented on this page was completed in 2020. It has not been regularly updated since its completion. This page is likely outdated and may be incomplete.


BP-Initials-UPDATED.png This Ballotpedia article is in need of updates. Please email us if you would like to suggest a revision. If you would like to help our coverage grow, consider donating to Ballotpedia.



This page contains information from a 2020 Ballotpedia survey about administrative due process and procedural rights. Ballotpedia reviewed the 50 state constitutions and administrative procedures acts (APAs) to determine which states place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication.

Placing the burden of proof on administrative agencies requires them to shoulder the responsibility of establishing the merits of their claims during adjudication.

Because state administrative agencies are not part of the judicial branch of government, adjudication proceedings before them do not necessarily afford the same procedural protections as in a courtroom trial. Ballotpedia conducted this survey in 2020 to see whether states give agencies the responsibility of proving their cases.

Understanding adjudication procedures provides insight into due process procedural rights of citizens at the state level. Procedural rights is one of the five pillars key to understanding the main areas of debate about the nature and scope of the administrative state.

According to the Ballotpedia survey, 2 state APAs placed the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication, as of November 2020. No state constitutions placed the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication at that time.

This page features the following sections:

In 2025, Ballotpedia updated the pillar system used to understand the main areas of debate about the nature and scope of the administrative state. Click here to learn more about this updated structure and to see Ballotpedia's current content related to the administrative state.



Background and methodology

Background

For this survey, Ballotpedia examined whether states place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication. Placing the burden of proof on administrative agencies requires them to shoulder the responsibility of establishing the merits of their claims during adjudication.

For instance, Hawaii placed "the burden of proof, including the burden of producing evidence as well as the burden of persuasion" on the party who initiates an adjudication proceeding, as of 2020. Under Hawaii's rules at that time, the burden of proof could fall on the agency or the regulated party.[1]

In Kentucky, by contrast, agencies had "the burden to show the propriety of a penalty imposed or the removal of a benefit previously granted," as of 2020.[2]

Methodology

Ballotpedia examined all 50 state constitutions and Administrative Procedure Acts (APAs) to see whether states place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication. Ballotpedia reviewed each provision involving agency adjudication to see whether states included such provisions.

In 2020, Ballotpedia concluded that Kentucky and North Carolina placed the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication because provisions in their APAs described certain cases in which agencies have the burden of proof. In most other states, the state APA placed the burden of proof on whoever initiated adjudication proceedings—either the state agency or a regulated person or business.

Administrative Procedure Acts (APAs) govern the procedures state administrative agencies must follow to issue regulations and adjudicate disputes. The particular procedures outlined in each APA vary among the 50 states.

Other state laws might place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication but those were beyond the scope of this survey.

To see the specific legal provisions Ballotpedia used to categorize each state, click here.

Summary of findings

Ballotpedia's survey of state constitutions and APAs produced the following key takeaways (as of November 2020):

  • 2 states had APAs with provisions that place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication as of 2020.
  • 48 states had APAs and constitutions that do not appear to place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication as of 2020.

Results: States that place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication

The table below includes each state in alphabetical order and indicates those that had specific provisions in their constitutions or APAs that placed the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication in 2020.

  • Done means that the state APA or constitution placed the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication
  • DefeatedA means that the state APA or constitution did not place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication

Other state laws that might place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication were beyond the scope of this survey.

State Constitution or APA provisions that place the burden of proof on administrative agencies during adjudication
Alabama DefeatedA
Alaska DefeatedA
Arizona DefeatedA
Arkansas DefeatedA
California DefeatedA
Colorado DefeatedA
Connecticut DefeatedA
Delaware DefeatedA
Florida DefeatedA
Georgia DefeatedA
Hawaii DefeatedA
Idaho DefeatedA
Illinois DefeatedA
Indiana DefeatedA
Iowa DefeatedA
Kansas DefeatedA
Kentucky Done
Louisiana DefeatedA
Maine DefeatedA
Maryland DefeatedA
Massachusetts DefeatedA
Michigan DefeatedA
Minnesota DefeatedA
Mississippi DefeatedA
Missouri DefeatedA
Montana DefeatedA
Nebraska DefeatedA
Nevada DefeatedA
New Hampshire DefeatedA
New Jersey DefeatedA
New Mexico DefeatedA
New York DefeatedA
North Carolina Done
North Dakota DefeatedA
Ohio DefeatedA
Oklahoma DefeatedA
Oregon DefeatedA
Pennsylvania DefeatedA
Rhode Island DefeatedA
South Carolina DefeatedA
South Dakota DefeatedA
Tennessee DefeatedA
Texas DefeatedA
Utah DefeatedA
Vermont DefeatedA
Virginia DefeatedA
Washington DefeatedA
West Virginia DefeatedA
Wisconsin DefeatedA
Wyoming DefeatedA

See also

Footnotes